Survey: Consumers Would Pay Premium for ‘Responsibly Mined’ Gold

SurveysJan 08, 2021

Survey: Consumers Would Pay Premium for ‘Responsibly Mined’ Gold

But they have very little knowledge about the area, indicating the trade needs to have clear messaging about origin and benefit to the buyer.

A shot of a gold miner in Mongolia (Photo courtesy Alliance for Responsible Mining)

Austin, Texas—Consumers have little knowledge about the origin of gold, according to one recent study, but after learning about it said they would pay a premium for certified responsibly-mined gold jewelry.

These insights were found in a research study about the awareness of responsibly sourced, artisanally mined gold conducted by MVI Marketing and Christina T. Miller Sustainable Jewelry Consulting.

It was co-sponsored by the Alliance for Responsible Mining and Rio Grande.

The survey polled 1,015 U.S. consumers between the ages of 25 and 50 from Nov. 4-13 with a household income greater than $50,000 and who have purchased jewelry valued at $200 or more in the past three years.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the study found consumers do not understand artisanal mining well, with less than 20 percent of survey takers even aware of the term “artisanal mining.”

Within that group, only one out of three correctly described artisanal gold as coming from individual or small-scale miners, results showed.

Twenty-four percent, meanwhile, said it was gold mined by hand in impoverished areas, which is accurate in some circumstances, but as many as 23 percent thought it referred to gold jewelry made by an artist.

Once educated in the area, survey takers said they are likely to spend more on products made with artisanal and small-scale certified responsible gold.

One out of three (33 percent) would pay 5 to 10 percent more while 41 percent would be willing to pay 11 percent or more.

(The survey defined ASM certified responsible gold for participants as gold from artisanal and small-scale gold mines that adhere to environmental, social, and economic standards, which are audited by an independent third-party.)

“Marketing messages must include the story behind the gold and the cost/benefit to the consumer of buying responsibly,” said survey conductors.

Interestingly, though, 44 percent of respondents also admitted if they found jewelry they liked that was not ASM certified responsible gold, they would still buy the piece.

Meanwhile, the survey also indicated gender does play a role in making these decisions, with men more likely to read details about products, expressing more interest in origin and environmental topics than women.

Age seemed to play a “minor factor” in consumer receptiveness to ASM certified responsible gold.

Almost half of respondents between 25 and 35 said they would choose it while 42 percent of those between 26 and 50 said they would do the same.


generations also consider origin and environmental issues more than older respondents.

The survey asked respondents to identify the issues that large companies and smaller miners face, and more than 60 percent understood dangerous working conditions as a top concern for both groups. Human rights abuses and poverty around the mining sites also were identified as important issues for artisanal and small-scale miners.

Most respondents also realize that mercury, which is commonly used in the artisanal and small-scale gold mining process, can have toxic effects on the nervous system and lead to brain damage, but 9 percent still mistakenly think mercury is safe to handle.

“This research study is a benchmark from which we will measure our progress as an industry,” said Christina Miller, an expert in the field of gold supply for jewelry manufacturing.

“The current conditions for artisanal and small-scale gold miners are neither healthy nor sustainable and this research shows that as consumers learn more, they will demand both transparent sourcing and improved conditions for the people doing the mining.”

What They Are Buying
The survey also asked participants about their jewelry buying habits and preferences, with one question asking them to rank what types of jewelry they were most likely to purchase.

Forty-five percent of respondents said they would purchase or request jewelry made with ASM certified responsible gold.

They also indicated they would purchase or request jewelry made with recycled gold (25 percent) and jewelry made with gold from industrial-scale mining companies (13 percent).

When ranking the most important criteria when buying fine jewelry, meanwhile, consumers ranked design as No. 1, followed by price and then metal.

Metal was seen as “extremely important” to 65 percent of the men in the study and 55 percent of the women, and “somewhat important” to 30 percent of men and 37 percent of women.

And in terms of preferred jewelry metal, 59 percent of women and 50 percent of men chose white gold for pieces they would purchase for themselves. This was followed by yellow gold, with 35 percent of women and 48 percent of men choosing the metal for themselves.

Meanwhile, gold and diamond jewelry was cited as the type of fine jewelry most purchased in the past three years, for both 55 percent of both men and women, followed by diamonds in sterling silver (46 percent for men and 41 percent of women).

Karat-gold jewelry with no gemstones or diamonds was the top choice for 50 percent of men in the survey.
Brecken Branstratoris the senior editor, gemstones at National Jeweler, covering sourcing, pricing and other developments in the colored stone sector.

The Latest

ColumnistsApr 20, 2021
Creative Connecting: You Need to Listen to This

Duvall O’Steen and Jen Cullen Williams on why jewelers should utilize two big audio platforms: podcasts and Clubhouse.

AuctionsApr 20, 2021
Christie’s to Offer 100-Carat Diamond at Auction This Spring

The D-color, internally flawless diamond leads the Geneva Magnificent Jewels auction.

IndependentsApr 20, 2021
Connecticut Jewelry Store To Close After 108 Years

Friedrich Jewelers owners Doug and Jacki Friedrich are ready for retirement.

Brought to you by
A New Golden Age

Gold has had its share of ups and downs over the last 5 decades. Here’s why the metal is having another big comeback.

GradingApr 19, 2021
Here’s What SSEF Found When It Studied High-Quality Afghan Emeralds

The Swiss lab reveals how stones from the Panjshir Valley are both different from and similar to emeralds from other places.

Weekly QuizApr 16, 2021
This Week's Quiz
Test your knowledge of jewelry news from the week of April 12-16, 2021.
Take the Quiz
CrimeApr 19, 2021
JSA Issues Refresher on What To Do During a Robbery

The reminder follows a frightening incident at a store in California.

Lab-GrownApr 19, 2021
Lab-Grown Diamond Co. Green Rocks Hires Brand Manager

Ahna Shmuel returns to the company to head brand management as well as oversee the jewelry division.

Brought to you by
4 Reasons You Need This Program for Mother’s Day

Learn how to increase customer loyalty and revenue by making JM™ Care Plan a cornerstone of your business plan.

WatchesApr 19, 2021
Watchfinder & Co. Names New CEO

Former Rakuten executive Arjen van de Vall will take the reins at the pre-owned watch retailer.