Majors

Tiffany triumphant in Costco trademark case

MajorsSep 08, 2015

Tiffany triumphant in Costco trademark case

Tiffany & Co. has notched a huge legal victory, with a federal judge granting its motion for summary judgement and rejecting arguments that the term “Tiffany” has become generic.

New York--Tiffany & Co. notched a huge legal victory this week, with a federal judge granting its motion for summary judgement in its lawsuit against Costco and rejecting arguments that the term “Tiffany” has become generic. 

U.S. District Judge Laura Taylor Swain granted Tiffany’s motions for summary judgement on claims of trademark infringement and trademark counterfeiting on Tuesday while dismissing Costco’s counterclaim that the “Tiffany” mark has become generic. 

Tiffany filed a lawsuit against Costco nearly three years ago, accusing the Issaquah, Wash.-based retailer of confusing consumers by selling rings in its stores with signs identifying them as “Tiffany” even though they aren’t genuine Tiffany & Co. rings. 

Costco fired back with a counterclaim alleging that “Tiffany setting” had been in use so long that it had become a generic term that could be used to describe any setting comprised of multiple slender prongs extending upward from a base to hold a single gemstone. 

Costco asked the court to declare invalid Tiffany’s federal trademark registrations that prevent other retailers from using the term “Tiffany setting.” 

While the court agreed to hear arguments about the term “Tiffany” being generic in terms of ring settings, it ultimately found that Tiffany has “proffered uncontroverted evidence demonstrating the strength of its mark,” Tuesday’s ruling states.

The judge writes in her decision that the most significant evidence is a report by Bain & Co. that states that Tiffany “claims the largest share of the female mind in the U.S.” when it comes to name recognition in jewelry brands. 

While Costco argued that “the plain word Tiffany … is ‘weak’ in many ways,” it didn’t gather any reliable evidence to back up its assertion, court papers state. 

The ruling also notes that Tiffany interviewed six different consumers who had purchased rings labeled as Tiffany at Costco and found that they all thought they had a genuine Tiffany & Co. ring. One woman even cried when the diamond fell out of what she believed was a Tiffany ring, court papers state.

A jury will determine punitive damages in the case at a later date. 

Costco did not respond to request for comment on the ruling by deadline. 

Tiffany filed suit against Costco Wholesale Corp. on Valentine’s Day 2013. 

According to the original suit, a shopper at a Costco in Huntington Beach, Calif. first made Tiffany aware that Costco was selling rings marked as Tiffany.
From there, the New York-based retailer launched its own investigation and, according to the lawsuit, eventually discovered that for years Costco had been selling rings in its stores with signs reading “Tiffany” but not labeling them as such online. This was done so Tiffany wouldn’t find out about it via its normal trademark policing procedures, the lawsuit states.

In a company statement issued late Tuesday, Tiffany general counsel Leigh Harlan said, “We are gratified that the court found that Costco’s use of the Tiffany trademark infringed on our rights. We believe this decision further validates the strength and value of the Tiffany mark and reinforces our continuing efforts to protect the brand.” 
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

Lab-GrownAug 12, 2022
Report: State Bank of India to Begin Lending to Lab-Grown Producers

The loans will go mostly to the import of machinery rather than working capital, according to a recent article from The Economic Times.

FinancialsAug 12, 2022
Brilliant Earth’s Fine Jewelry a Hit in Q2

The company is also continuing its retail expansion.

AuctionsAug 12, 2022
2 Rolexes Paul Newman Gave to Stuntman Stan Barrett Head to Auction

The sale also will include a third Rolex, with all three watches tied to Barrett’s 1979 attempt to break the world record for land speed.

Brought to you by
The American Mined™ Collection: Ethical Sourcing That Matters

Rio Grande provides a pathway to responsibly sourced gemstones.

CollectionsAug 12, 2022
Piece of the Week: İTÄ Jewelry’s ‘Danza’ Ring

It mixes diamond shapes and colors.

Weekly QuizAug 11, 2022
This Week’s Quiz
Test your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
Take the Quiz
Supplier BulletinAug 11, 2022
AGTA GemFair™ Denver – Back and Better Than Before!

Sponsored by AGTA

AuctionsAug 11, 2022
Sotheby’s Is Preparing its First Art Jewelry Auction This Fall

“Art as Jewelry as Art” features works from artists like Salvador Dalí, Alexander Calder, and Max Ernst.

Brought to you by
Knowledge and Skills for Today’s Hot Topics

From laboratory-grown diamonds to design to country-of-origin, GIA's Alumni Collective™ has a seminar to suite your needs.

IndependentsAug 11, 2022
Martin Katz Is Moving to a Penthouse

The jeweler is relocating his Beverly Hills store after 20 years and has begun developing a lifestyle brand.

Events & AwardsAug 11, 2022
HRD Antwerp Is Bringing Back Its Jewelry Design Competition

The Belgian organization is calling for entries from all over the world, with an eye on attracting emerging talent.

ColumnistsAug 10, 2022
On Data: What We Know About Jewelry Sales So Far This Year

Sherry Smith digs into year-to-date data on lab-grown vs. natural diamonds, the performance of colored gemstone jewelry, and more.

EditorsAug 10, 2022
Take a Tour Through Buccellati’s Vintage Jewelry Collection

Associate Editor Lenore Fedow leads readers through the Italian jeweler’s works from the 1940s to the 2000s.

CrimeAug 10, 2022
Smash-and-Grab NY Thieves Flee with $2M in Jewels

The NYPD is still searching for the four suspects who robbed Rocco’s Jewelry in the Bronx.

Events & AwardsAug 10, 2022
JA New York Returns with New Designer Gallery

The jewelry trade show is taking place Aug. 14-16 at the Javits Center in New York City.

MajorsAug 09, 2022
Signet to Buy Blue Nile in $360M Deal

The jewelry giant said the acquisition will allow it to tap into a pool of customers who are younger, more affluent and ethnically diverse.

TechnologyAug 09, 2022
Tiffany & Co.’s CryptoPunk Pendant NFTs Are Sold Out

There were only 250 made available, selling for more than $50,000.

CollectionsAug 09, 2022
Cora Sheibani Shows a Magic Garden of Jewelry at Sotheby’s

The British-based Swiss designer’s “Pottering Around” collection is for sale at Sotheby’s East Hampton starting this week.

SourcingAug 09, 2022
Diamond Price List Introduces ‘Insights’ Platform

It provides real-time diamond market analytics.

SourcingAug 09, 2022
Grandview Klein to Donate Dialysis Machines to Namibian Clinic

The diamond firm will give the donation at a ceremony in Namibia this month during a trip for select retail jeweler partners.

CrimeAug 08, 2022
Nehal Modi Sentenced to 3-9 Years in Grand Larceny Case

He was convicted last month after falsely claiming he had a deal with Costco in order to obtain millions in diamonds from LLD Diamonds USA.

TrendsAug 08, 2022
Amanda’s Style File: Spicy Spinels

Tough, vibrant, and full of personality, spinel is a perfect birthstone for August babies, Amanda Gizzi says.

IndependentsAug 08, 2022
Gemist, NDC to Offer Custom Pieces by BIPOC Designers

Dorian Webb, one of the designers in the Emerging Designers Diamond Initiative, will be the first to work with Gemist.

MajorsAug 08, 2022
Here’s How to Support Jewelers for Children this JFC Day

The charity will hold its fifth annual fundraising day on Sept. 24.

SourcingAug 05, 2022
Rare Earth Mining Co.’s Bill Heher Dies at 72

The passionate gem lover helped bring more than 300 different varieties of stones to the gem trade.

TrendsAug 05, 2022
Piece of the Week: Storrow Jewelry’s ‘Emblem Rosa’ Charm

The brand has attracted attention for its colorful, vintage-inspired pieces.

MajorsAug 05, 2022
Former Nike Executive Joins Team at David Yurman

Marcelo Tau is the company’s new chief operations officer.

Policies & IssuesAug 05, 2022
Satta Matturi Joins RJC Board

The jewelry designer founded her eponymous brand in 2015 after nearly two decades in the diamond industry.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy