Op-Ed: Can the Kimberley Process Get it Right in CAR?

SourcingApr 06, 2016

Op-Ed: Can the Kimberley Process Get it Right in CAR?

As the KP readies to green-light rough diamond exports from one area of the Central African Republic, the Enough Project’s Brad Brooks-Rubin says yes, the process can succeed there.

Since it launched in 2003, there has been one essential question facing the Kimberley Process (KP): Does it work?  

Brad Brooks-Rubin is policy director of the Enough Project and its investigative initiative, The Sentry. A non-governmental organization (NGO), the Enough Project works to build leverage for peace and justice in Africa, engaging with the Kimberley Process principally through its work in the Central African Republic.

This deceptively simple question elicits very strong and often diametrically opposed views. Many in industry and government believe it an unparalleled success, a bold step unlike that taken for any other commodity in the world. Others claim it to be a disappointment, an institution unable and often even unwilling to deal with the toughest issues, especially when dealing with exporting diamonds from conflict or post-conflict zones.  

The KP’s greatest past challenges in addressing conflict-affected and illicitly traded diamonds--Liberia, Cote d’Ivoire, Zimbabwe--can be used to illustrate success or failure depending almost entirely on your starting perspective. Although each case was different and complex in its own way, and space does not permit us to revisit the details of each here, at the height of those crises, stakeholders within the KP held different views about whether, when and how to permit rough diamond exports. They also diverged on what to do when the situations changed.

As the KP prepares to partially ease the nearly three-year-old suspension of rough diamond exports from the Central African Republic (CAR), the KP and broader industry urgently need to rise above past disagreements. Now is the time for constructive and collaborative action in responsibly regulating the diamond trade in this conflict- and corruption-torn country.

The headline is that the KP is set to permit exports from the Berbérati zone, a mining area in the southwestern part of CAR.

This breakthrough follows a carefully negotiated and thoughtful process agreed upon in June 2015, which included multiple levels of review within the KP, the strong engagement of the CAR authorities and a local implementation committee and substantial information and data collection processes. The potential for progress in Berbérati is to the credit of the KP and many local actors and shows the benefit of fully engaged, multi-stakeholder coordination. 

But now that exports are expected to resume soon, the KP and broader industry must redouble diligence efforts and be willing to adjust, rather than see this as a time to ease
up. Exports may begin in the coming weeks or months, once the CAR authorities notify the KP Monitoring Team that an export parcel should be reviewed for approval and the team agrees that the parcel meets the guidelines for export. (A description of the full process is available on the Kimberley Process website.) 

Vigilance is required because of situation on the ground. Although only mining areas in and around the town of Berbérati are officially approved, it’s possible for diamonds from other, non-approved mining areas to be brought to the approved areas and then move out for export without any direct means of assurance.  

There are few, if any, mining officials or law enforcement regularly deployed to the mining areas, and some of the mines in the Berbérati zone are up to 30 miles away from town, through thick forest. Baseline production data for the Berbérati zone has not been officially established yet, which is critical for the creation of a production footprint or statistical tools that can evaluate whether these leakages are occurring. In sum, the danger of the wrong diamonds getting into the system is very real.

Beyond this general concern of traceability, which is frankly true of many KP-producing countries, armed gangs remain in the area. Though less numerous than in other parts of CAR, it is difficult for KP teams and other observers to get access to the mines themselves, due to logistical challenges and limited financial support. As such, the KP and industry should be prepared to react decisively should credible reports emerge that diamonds formally exported from Berbérati are either (a) not from that region or (b) connected to conflict. If there are such reports, the KP must be prepared to pause and adapt the system to ensure that only conflict-free diamonds are exported.

Responding to these situations will require vigilance, flexibility and commitment to the existing processes.  

An effective KP regime in CAR includes the following key measures. 

--In CAR, the government’s KP authorities and the broader mechanisms established by the KP need to take all possible steps to ensure that only diamonds from the approved zone are actually exported. Illicit actors should be pursued and excluded from trade and prosecuted. This will require substantial capacity-building of local civil society and community actors, something that the KP’s participants and observers, as well as broader industry, should be prepared to support financially.  

--In the key trading and manufacturing centers for CAR production, specifically Antwerp, Dubai, Tel Aviv and Mumbai, KP authorities should be communicating to industry actors about the need to demonstrate meaningful due diligence to ensure that diamonds from outside Berbérati are not mixed with approved production. Illicit diamond trade from CAR may also connect to concerns such as money laundering, areas the KP and industry must do more to address. As such, the World Diamond Council and other industry bodies should inform the trade about the KP’s steps and ensure necessary vigilance. Where authorities discover violations or suspicious activity, action should be taken and reported publicly.

--The KP should not add additional export zones until sufficient time has passed, e.g., in time for the 2016 KP Plenary in November, to evaluate whether this system is workable. This should include public and transparent reporting by the KP and CAR authorities about progress and challenges.

--All stakeholders should prioritize support for artisanal mining development programs so the people of CAR begin to see the benefits of this precious resource.

--The United Nation’s peacekeeping mission in CAR, MINUSCA, should also play a role in these efforts by deploying to key areas and appointing a senior natural resource expert.

Should the KP or industry identify problems, the system agreed upon should rapidly react, even if that means suspending exports again until concerns are resolved.

If the stakeholders of the rough diamond trade demonstrate they are capable of being flexible and honest in the face of difficult issues, the KP will finally be able to prove to everyone that, in fact, it works.   

Brad Brooks-Rubin is policy director of the Enough Project and its investigative initiative, The Sentry. He was special adviser for conflict diamonds at the U.S. Department of State from 2009 to 2013 and also served at the U.S. Department of the Treasury and GIA. Reach him at 
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

EditorsMay 25, 2022
7 Standout Tiaras in Sotheby’s Platinum Jubilee Exhibition

Senior Editor Brecken Branstrator chooses the pieces she’d most want to see in person.

MajorsMay 25, 2022
Anne Hathaway Is Bulgari’s Newest Ambassador

The actress joins Zendaya and others in a new advertising campaign.

IndependentsMay 25, 2022
The Mexican Shack to Close After 47 Years

Owner Steve Delzio shares his thoughts on retirement after nearly five decades in the jewelry industry.

Brought to you by
Dive into GIA’s Pearl Expertise

When it comes to knowing the identity and quality of your pearls, count on GIA as your independent pearl experts.

IndependentsMay 25, 2022
Designer Theo Fennell Has Written a Memoir

“I Fear for This Boy” takes readers through the ups and downs of his business and is available for pre-order now.

Weekly QuizMay 19, 2022
This Week’s Quiz
Test your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
Take the Quiz
IndependentsMay 25, 2022
MVEye, Wedding Report Partner on New Jewelry Research Platform

“Today’s Wedding Jewelry Consumer” shares data about engagement ring market size, lab-grown and natural diamonds, and more.

ColumnistsMay 24, 2022
The PR Adviser: 10 Questions to Contemplate

Columnist Lilian Raji wants to walk you through the customer journey. But first, she’d like you to answer a few questions.

Brought to you by
A.I. Grading is Changing Conversations at the Retail Counter

Advanced technology levels the playing field, helping jewelers give customers what they want.

Events & AwardsMay 24, 2022
8 Gold Jewelry Designers Unveil New Platinum Designs

Several Couture brands have partnered with Platinum Guild International ahead of the jewelry trade show.

Lab-GrownMay 24, 2022
Kendra Scott Unveils Lab-Grown Engagement Ring Collection

The jewelry company is moving into bridal just a month after branching out into the watch world.

Events & AwardsMay 24, 2022
WJA to Host Diversity Keynote at New Las Vegas Breakfast Event

The Generating Community Impact fundraiser on June 11 will feature Karine Bah Tahé of Blue Level Training.

WatchesMay 23, 2022
Steven Kaiser, Watch Industry Veteran and Beloved Mentor, Dies at 68

Kaiser, whose illustrious career spanned decades, died suddenly on Friday.

IndependentsMay 23, 2022
Long’s Jewelers to Open New Location

The family-owned jeweler is relocating its Braintree, Massachusetts, store to a new space.

IndependentsMay 23, 2022
Luxury Goods Veteran Olivier Stip Joins Chicago Jeweler CD Peacock

He will step into the retailer’s newly created role of chief development officer.

GradingMay 23, 2022
Gem-A Launches Digital Entry-Level Gemology Course

GemIntro is meant to give a broad introduction to gems and gemology.

Recorded WebinarsMay 20, 2022
Watch: Responsible Sourcing and the Gold Supply Chain

Three industry experts discuss “recycled” gold vs. mined, their challenges and benefits, and how jewelers can navigate the area.

FinancialsMay 20, 2022
Richemont’s 2022 Jewelry Sales in the Americas Nearly Double

Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, and Buccellati put on stellar performances.

AuctionsMay 20, 2022
Piece of the Week: ‘Birds in Flight’ by Oscar Heyman

The New York jeweler made this incredible, colorful Art Deco bracelet featuring tropical birds in 1927.

SurveysMay 19, 2022
5 Predictions for Jewelry Retail in the Second Half of 2022

From a slowdown in sales growth to rising costs, Fruchtman Marketing outlines its expectations for the second half of the year.

MajorsMay 19, 2022
As It Nears 75, Here’s How Grandview Klein Stays Competitive

Once a part of Julius Klein Group, the diamond company combines its direct supply and cutting expertise with a keen eye to the future.

CollectionsMay 19, 2022
Brilliant Earth Collaborates with Jade Trau

The two have partnered on a capsule collection.

MajorsMay 19, 2022
Jewelers Mutual Adds 2 Industry Veterans to Its Board

John A. Green of retailer Lux Bond & Green and Niveet Nagpal of Omi Privé have joined the board of directors as of May 18.

FinancialsMay 18, 2022
Watches of Switzerland’s Jewelry Sales More Than Doubled in Q4

The retailer also said demand for Rolex, Patek Philippe, and Audemars Piguet watches continues to exceed its supply.

AuctionsMay 18, 2022
Jewels from Bette Midler Are Headed to Bonhams

The auction house’s upcoming sale also includes collections from American heiresses.

IndependentsMay 18, 2022
Jeweler Lewis Baribault Celebrates 50th Work Anniversary

The Connecticut jeweler reflected on five decades in the industry and what the future holds for the family business.

Events & AwardsMay 18, 2022
Visit A Mine in New Jersey With WJA New York Metro

The chapter has organized a day trip to the Sterling Hill Mine and Museum in Ogdensburg on Saturday, May 21.

SourcingMay 17, 2022
A New Source in Tanzania Is Producing Cobalt-Blue Spinel

The stones come from a deposit close to Mahenge and have been on the market for several months.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy