3 Thoughts About the New Campaign for Diamonds

EditorsOct 26, 2016

3 Thoughts About the New Campaign for Diamonds

Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff gauges the online reaction and shares her initial impressions of “Real is Rare.”

The Diamond Producers Association’s “Real is Rare” campaign has launched with two commercials, “Runaways” and “Wild & Kind,” a screenshot of which is seen here.
The Diamond Producers Association recently introduced “Real is Rare,” the new marketing campaign designed to stoke millennials’ interest in diamonds.

Now, let me start this blog by saying that it’s way too early to pass any judgements on the success or failure of the campaign, which is only about three weeks old.

I believe the real tell for “Real is Rare” will be more long term. It won’t be gauged on the comments sections of social media sites but, rather, at the cash registers in jewelry stores in coming years.

And the Diamond Producers Association knows that; they don’t expect this campaign to move the needle on diamond jewelry demand overnight.

As DPA Chairman Stephen Lussier noted at the campaign’s launch party held earlier this month in New York, “We’re not setting out to transform Christmas this year, or even perhaps Christmas next (year), although I’d like to think we’d have a positive impact.

“Our real mission here is the long-term foundation of making sure that these consumers now, these millennials ... that they have this belief in the diamond dream.”

That being said, here are a few thoughts in the immediate wake of the launch of “Real is Rare” with some insights from the DPA’s Chief Marketing Officer Deborah Marquardt, who took time to chat with me on the phone on Monday.

1. The negative comments aren’t anything new. On social media, they mostly are along the lines of diamonds aren’t really rare, the whole diamond engagement ring thing is a scam perpetrated by De Beers to sell more diamonds (as if De Beers is the only company in the world to ever successfully market its product), they’re all “blood diamonds,” etc.

I actually asked Lussier about the whole “rare” approach when I interviewed him in June after the DPA debuted the “Real is Rare” tagline in Las Vegas; was there any hesitation on the DPA’s part about the word “rare” being used? 

Lussier told me then that the “diamonds aren’t rare” argument didn’t come up when consumers were interviewed during the campaign’s development, though he did allow that consumers “recognize that there are rare ones (meaning diamonds) and there are less rare ones, particularly when it comes to size and quality.”

Overall, though, Lussier said he doesn’t see the use of the word “rare” being an issue. He also pointed out that in the campaign, “rare” references the rarity of real connections in today’s digital world, not the diamonds themselves.
On YouTube, the DPA has posted the commercials but said it has had to disable comments for both because people were posting “really hateful comments” that had nothing to do with the campaign, Marquardt said.

I, personally, would have opted to simply weed out the negative remarks rather than disable comments entirely, given the fact that not being able to comment definitely won’t go unnoticed by the members of the generation at whom this campaign is aimed. (And, in fact, it hasn’t; check out the comments section of this AdWeek story.)

When I asked Marquardt about it, she said the DPA sees YouTube primarily as a platform for video viewing while Twitter, Instagram and Facebook are the platforms where they really want the dialogue to happen.

And it is happening, as there are both positive and negative remarks about the campaign on social media.

“We would love it, of course, if everybody loved everything, but I think what’s most important is if people are talking, then we are breaking through,” she said.

For anybody who wants to check it out the campaign’s content and comments, “Real is Rare” can be found on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram by searching @RealisaDiamond while the hashtag for the campaign is #RealisRare.

(The DPA went with @RealisaDiamond over @RealisRare because @RealisaDiamond was available across all platforms.)

2. Is it too unconventional? There’s a lot of “wild” going on in both commercials but, interestingly enough, there aren’t any traditional engagement rings.

In “Runaways” the couple runs off together after their first date, first to his apartment, then to Thailand, then to a third floor walk-up (Where? Should we guess Brooklyn? And, on that note, does anybody in any type of advertising today not look like they live in Brooklyn? ) before finally settling in a remote locale where chickens run free.

Meanwhile, in “Wild & Kind” the couple is committed to a life together but is unsure if they’ll ever formally tie the knot.

One Midwest retailer seems to think it might be a bit too much wild for his customers, writing in the comments section of our last story on the campaign that the DPA, “might be missing out on regional opportunities to create ads for those ‘traditional’ Gen-Xers who might still believe in carrying on the old ways.”

“We out here in the fly-over states still have the same problem,” with diamond sales, he wrote. “They are not being told to buy bigger diamonds or on more occasions. We need their (the DPA’s) support too.”

You can read the retailer’s entire comment on “Real is Rare” here.

One of the 20-something, New York City-based editors here said the same when I asked for her feedback.

While for the most part she likes the direction of the campaign, she did note that it “kind of feels like they are trying a little too hard to be ‘alternative’ and non-traditional.”

“I wonder if they might be missing out by not doing any commercials yet that are more traditional, just helping build the value of a diamond and keeping it as the symbol for marriage and the idea of ‘forever’ in that sense?” she asked.

I asked Marquardt about this when we talked on Monday and she hinted that some more traditional ads were coming down the pike, with “successive waves of communication” set to roll out throughout the end of the year and into 2017.

It was a “conscious decision” by the DPA to launch with the campaign with ads that were more non-traditional, she said, “but it is in no way to say that engagement and marriage and traditional commitment aren’t going to be addressed in the campaign.”

In talking with Marquardt about the less-traditional nature of these first few ads, I also got an answer to my next question, which was …

3. Is there going to be a commercial that includes a same-sex couple? When the DPA screened the ads for members of the industry and press in New York, they told the audience there were going to be two ads.

So I--along with a few of the people seated near me--figured we’d see one ad with a man-woman pair and another with a gay or lesbian couple. I was a bit surprised when both commercials featured a man and a woman together.

While Marquardt can’t share many specifics about what’s next, she did note that “we have a 360 campaign that celebrates many types of relationships and is reflective of our society today.”

Some might think we are living in times that are overly political correct, but I think it’s just what is right. If we are in the business of celebrating love, then all types of love need to be represented.

What do you think of what you’ve seen of “Real is Rare” so far? Have your customers said anything about it? Leave your comments below or email me at michelle.graff@nationaljeweler.com.

Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

AuctionsSep 30, 2022
Red Diamond Earns $1.8M at Auction

The final hammer price blew the pre-sale estimate out of the water.

Policies & IssuesSep 30, 2022
Voting Is Open for the Fairmined 100 Challenge’s Best Collection

The winners, picked by a group of judges and voted as the public’s favorite, will be announced in a webinar on Oct. 11.

CollectionsSep 30, 2022
Piece of the Week: Fewer Finer’s ‘Family Bracelet’

The engravable piece is a perfect family heirloom.

Brought to you by
6 Steps to Start a Dynamic Company Culture

Learn how to better serve your employees, customers and community by having a dynamic and supportive company culture.

GradingSep 30, 2022
GSI India Names Ramit Kapur Managing Director

Kapur has spent nearly two decades working in the gemological labs sector of the jewelry industry.

Weekly QuizSep 29, 2022
This Week’s Quiz
Test your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
Take the Quiz
Supplier BulletinSep 29, 2022
How to Create an Engaging Experience and a Sparkling Reputation

Sponsored by Synchrony

SourcingSep 29, 2022
Q&A: Constantin Wild Celebrates 175 Years in the Colored Stone Business

The family business’ fourth-generation eponymous owner reflects on the milestone and the market today.

Brought to you by
Committing to an Ethical Diamond Business

While ethical mining is essential to a diamond business, they represent only a fraction of the responsibility bestowed on jewelers.

AuctionsSep 29, 2022
See the Top Lots in Christie’s Upcoming Rare Watch Sale

According to Christie’s, the auction is its most important single-owner watch collection ever.

CollectionsSep 29, 2022
Trove Has a New Proposal: Ring Boxes

The jewelry box brand is expanding with both single and double ring boxes in red, mint green, and white.

SourcingSep 29, 2022
AGTA Names Jennifer Heebner Editor-in-Chief of its Publications

The association has also hired a new marketing manager and announced two staff transitions.

Policies & IssuesSep 29, 2022
JA Members Return to Capitol Hill to Voice Jewelers’ Concerns

The topics up for discussion with lawmakers included inflation, rising interest rates, hiring challenges, and crime.

AuctionsSep 28, 2022
The 18-Carat ‘Fortune Pink’ Diamond Could Sell for $35M

The pear-shaped fancy vivid pink diamond will lead the Christie’s Geneva Magnificent Jewels auction on Nov. 8.

SurveysSep 28, 2022
Consumer Confidence Rises in September

U.S. consumer confidence rose for the second consecutive month as gas prices fell.

MajorsSep 28, 2022
Artistry’s 2023 Catalog Is Out Now

The jewelry catalog features an updated layout and 160 pages of product.

MajorsSep 28, 2022
JFC’s 2022 ‘Hope for the Holidays’ Program Is an Adorable Menagerie

There are three designs to choose from this year, all featuring animals drawn by kids who have had wishes granted through Make-A-Wish.

AuctionsSep 27, 2022
In Betty White’s Blockbuster Estate Sale, Jewelry Held Its Own

Fine jewelry comprised three of the auction’s top 10 lots, though it could not top her director’s chair or scripts from “The Golden Girls.”

CrimeSep 27, 2022
3 Suspects in Beverly Hills Smash-and-Grab Robbery Arrested

A total of four suspects are now in custody with police still on the lookout for the remaining two.

ColumnistsSep 27, 2022
Creative Connecting: Fun Ideas for Holiday 2022 In-Store Events

From a “whodunnit” murder mystery to a permanent jewelry party, Duvall O’Steen and Jen Cullen Williams share a wealth of suggestions.

MajorsSep 27, 2022
Stuller Releases 2 Updated Catalogs Ahead of the Holiday Season

“Mountings 2023-2024” and “Diamonds & Gemstones 2023-2024” offer a vast selection of options to create custom pieces.

Events & AwardsSep 27, 2022
ICA’s 2023 Congress Will Be Held in Dubai

The event will be hosted by the Dubai Multi Commodities Centre from Feb. 15-17.

IndependentsSep 26, 2022
Roberson’s Fine Jewelry to Close After 42 Years

The store’s liquidation sale will showcase the mix of classic and unique jewels it’s known for stocking.

CollectionsSep 26, 2022
Go ‘Inside the Dream’ of Bulgari Via a New Documentary on Amazon Prime

It follows Creative Director Lucia Silvestri as she crafts the brand’s high jewelry collections.

Recorded WebinarsSep 26, 2022
Watch: What Jewelers Should Know About Insurance

From safeguarding showcases to appraisal liability, insurance experts Mark Devereaux and Andrew Chipman share insurance tips for jewelers.

TrendsSep 26, 2022
Vahan Collabs With Wolf on a Jewelry Box

It’s the first time in 50 years the brand has made something other than jewelry.

Events & AwardsSep 26, 2022
Texas Jewelers Association Rolls Out New Format for Design Competition

The competition takes place in tandem with TJA’s annual convention, known as the Texas Jewelers Roundup.

CollectionsSep 23, 2022
Pandora Reimagines Keith Haring’s Art in New Collection

The limited-run collection features figures from Haring’s iconic street art on charms, bracelets, rings, and more.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy