SourcingApr 18, 2024
Diamond Trade Remains Cautious Amid Economic UncertaintyDe Beers’ rough diamond sales were down 18 percent year-over-year in its latest round of sales.
EditorsFeb 24, 2014
A litigious follow-up
When I arrived at work on Friday morning, a headline relating to the big news that has the industry buzzing--the pending merger of Signet and Zale--caught my eye immediately. “Signet to Buy Zale, Law Firms Cry Foul” it read, with the corresponding article going on to list five, just to “name a few,” law firms that are “investigating” the deal.
Though I did not find a quote quite like this anywhere else, all of the releases were basically the same, and all issued a call to action, so to speak, asking shareholders who want additional information concerning their legal rights to contact the law firm.
Zale, for its part, said it had no comment on any of these law firms’ statements. But a few people I spoke with in the industry confirmed what I had suspected: that these types of investigations are not at all uncommon today.
There was an interesting post on this topic published in March 2013 on a Harvard Law School blog. The article, which came from Cornerstone Research and was an analysis of a report by Cornerstone’s principal researcher and a Stanford Law School professor on M&A litigation in 2012 deals, states that “continuing a recent trend, shareholders challenged the vast majority of M&A (merger and acquisition) deals in 2012.”
The more money there is at stake, the more challenges there are. A total of 93 percent of deals valued at more than $100 million were challenged, with an average of 4.8 lawsuits per deal, according to the research. This number climbed to 96 percent and an average of 5.4 lawsuits for deals valued at more than $500 million. The proposed Signet-Zale merger is worth more than double this amount at $1.4 billion.
In most of these lawsuits, which generally take the form of class actions (hence the firms’ calls for anyone with questions about their “legal rights” to contact them), the arguments include failure to conduct a sale that was competitive enough or conflicts of interest, which can include executive retention or change-of-control payments to executives, according to the research.
On the first point, it is
difficult to say exactly just how competitive a sale such as this could be. In other words: What other companies would have wanted Zale? Fine jewelry is a very specialized business and, as consultant Ben Janowski stated in my analysis piece published Thursday, “Who was going to buy them (Zale)? The only reasonable, logical buyer was Signet all along.” Signet, longtime industry analyst Ken Gassman points out, is the only player with the both the “fit” and the money; Tiffany & Co. might have the money, but Zale’s middle-market stores are not a fit for its brand.
One possible angle the attorneys could try to take is that Terry Burman, the former Signet CEO who was appointed to head Zale’s board in May 2013, had a deal in place before he even agreed to become Zale’s chairman, Gassman said. Lawyers will want to know if Golden Gate Capital, the company that issued Zale a $150 million lifeline in 2010 and owns a 22 percent stake in the company, is paying Burman a “finder’s fee” for obtaining a premium-to-market price, he said.
But, the general consensus seems to be that none of these investigations will amount to much; or, as Gassman put it, “I’d tell the lawyers to go home and try to find dirt on some other deal.”
Perhaps a few will result in lawsuits, but it seems likely those will get settled rather quickly. The authors of the Cornerstone article said that of the lawsuits relating to 2012 M&A deals for which they were able to determine the outcome, 64 percent settled an average of 42 days after they were filed. The plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed 33 percent of the suits and the remaining 3 percent were dismissed by the courts.
Anyone familiar with litigation knows that 42 days is an incredibly short time to settle a lawsuit, considering many suits--think the De Beers class-action--drag on for years. But it doesn’t seem likely that this will be the case here, and the merger should go through and close as expected by the end of 2014.
One possible angle the attorneys could try to take is that Terry Burman, the former Signet CEO who was appointed to head Zale’s board in May 2013, had a deal in place before he even agreed to become Zale’s chairman, Gassman said. Lawyers will want to know if Golden Gate Capital, the company that issued Zale a $150 million lifeline in 2010 and owns a 22 percent stake in the company, is paying Burman a “finder’s fee” for obtaining a premium-to-market price, he said.
But, the general consensus seems to be that none of these investigations will amount to much; or, as Gassman put it, “I’d tell the lawyers to go home and try to find dirt on some other deal.”
Perhaps a few will result in lawsuits, but it seems likely those will get settled rather quickly. The authors of the Cornerstone article said that of the lawsuits relating to 2012 M&A deals for which they were able to determine the outcome, 64 percent settled an average of 42 days after they were filed. The plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed 33 percent of the suits and the remaining 3 percent were dismissed by the courts.
Anyone familiar with litigation knows that 42 days is an incredibly short time to settle a lawsuit, considering many suits--think the De Beers class-action--drag on for years. But it doesn’t seem likely that this will be the case here, and the merger should go through and close as expected by the end of 2014.
More on Editors
The Latest
Supplier BulletinApr 18, 2024
Discover History’s Hidden Gems at the Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch ShowSponsored by the Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch Show
WatchesApr 18, 2024
Watch E-tailer Collectability Hires Kelly YochThe Patek Philippe expert will serve as personal curator for the brand-focused company.
Brought to you by
The Blueprint for Success in Scalable, Personalized Jewelry RetailWith Ho Brothers, you can unlock your brand's true potential and offer customers the personalized jewelry experiences they desire.
WatchesApr 18, 2024
TAG Heuer Opens Its Largest Standalone Boutique at SeaThe 553-square-foot shop is aboard the Carnival Jubilee cruise ship.
Weekly QuizApr 11, 2024
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge with this seven-question quiz.
Policies & IssuesApr 17, 2024
NDC Prevails in U.K. Case Over Lab-Grown Diamond AdvertisingNDC filed a complaint against Skydiamond for use of phrases like “diamonds made entirely from the sky.”
Events & AwardsApr 17, 2024
And the 2024 Winner of the Shipley Award Is … John Carter received the AGS’s highest honor Tuesday afternoon at Conclave in Austin, Texas.
Brought to you by
How Jewelers of America Represents Your BusinessFor over 30 years, JA has advocated for the industry, fought against harmful legislation and backed measures that help jewelry businesses.
FinancialsApr 17, 2024
LVMH’s Q1 Jewelry Sales Fall 5%LVMH said the company performed well despite an uncertain geopolitical and economic environment.
MajorsApr 17, 2024
Stuller’s B&D Opens New HeadquartersB&D Sales and Service held a ribbon-cutting event for its new location in Cranston, Rhode Island.
CollectionsApr 16, 2024
Akaila Reid Launches ‘Eat Cake’ CollectionIt’s ultra-feminine and filled with gold, pearls, and soft pastels.
MajorsApr 16, 2024
Loudr Adds 2 DirectorsEmily Highet Morgan and Emily Bennett have joined the agency’s team.
MajorsApr 16, 2024
Stuller Releases First Lab-Grown Diamond Jewelry CatalogIts updated book for mountings is also now available.
SourcingApr 16, 2024
Karen Rentmeesters Takes Over as Interim CEO of AWDCShe has been with the organization since 2010, most recently serving as its chief officer of PR and industry relations.
TechnologyApr 15, 2024
Judge Rules Jeweler’s Lawsuit Against PNC Bank Can Move ForwardJoyce’s Jewelry sued the bank after cybercriminals drained its accounts of nearly $1.6 million through a series of wire transfers.
IndependentsApr 15, 2024
Alfred W. DeScenza of DeScenza Diamonds Dies at 95He is remembered by loved ones for his loyalty, integrity, and kindness.
AuctionsApr 15, 2024
Madeleine K. Albright Jewelry, Pins Coming to AuctionHosted by Freeman’s | Hindman, the sale will take place May 7-8.
AuctionsApr 15, 2024
All of Sotheby’s ‘Rough Diamonds’ Sold in Less Than an HourThe auction house said all 24 timepieces offered in its underground sale of rare and avant-garde watches quickly found buyers.
Events & AwardsApr 15, 2024
10 Can’t-Miss Sessions at AGS Conclave 2024From lab-grown diamonds and AI to the inevitable Taylor Swift mention, here are some of Conclave’s most intriguing educational offerings.
Recorded WebinarsApr 12, 2024
Watch: What Jewelers Need to Know About InsuranceFrom cybersecurity liability to trade show coverage, insurance experts share tips on how to build the right policy.
CollectionsApr 12, 2024
Piece of the Week: Lionheart’s Evil Eye Gemstone CharmThe charm is a modern rendition of the evil eye amulet that has been worn for thousands of years.
Events & AwardsApr 12, 2024
The Jewelry Symposium Announces 4 Scholarship WinnersAhead of its trade show next month, TJS awarded free registration and accommodations to one jewelry professional and three students.
Policies & IssuesApr 11, 2024
SRK Exports’ Journey Toward Net Zero Impact By the end of this year, SRK’s diamond manufacturing complexes will achieve net zero emissions, one of an impressive array of achievements.
Lab-GrownApr 11, 2024
AGTA Bans Lab-Grown Diamonds, Gemstones at GemFairMembers can still sell lab-grown stones, it said, but only natural gems are allowed on the show floor.
IndependentsApr 11, 2024
Steven Rosdal, Co-Founder of Hyde Park Jewelers, Dies at 77He is remembered for his charisma, passion, integrity, kindness, and wit.
MajorsApr 11, 2024
Macy’s Opens Books for Possible BuyoutThe retailer also appointed two new board members, avoiding a proxy fight from a potential buyer.
CollectionsApr 10, 2024
Sylvie Launches New Nature-Inspired Collection, ‘Tulira’The bridal collection consists of 35 engagement rings and seven wedding bands.
