NDC Prevails in U.K. Case Over Lab-Grown Diamond Advertising
NDC filed a complaint against Skydiamond for use of phrases like “diamonds made entirely from the sky.”
London—The U.K.’s Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) announced it has upheld the Natural Diamond Council’s complaint against retailer Skydiamond for misleading marketing and advertisement of lab-grown diamonds.
The online fine jewelry retailer uses a patented process to create diamonds from atmospheric carbon dioxide and rainwater using renewable energy from solar and wind power, its website states.
The NDC’s complaint alleged that it was misleading for Skydiamond to use the terms “Skydiamonds,” “diamonds,” and “diamonds made entirely from the sky” in ads it featured in early 2023 in press, on its Instagram, and on its website.
It also called into question the use of the words “real diamond” in a section of the retailer’s FAQ page that answered the question “Are Skydiamonds real diamonds?” with “Each Skydiamond is a perfectly formed real diamond.”
In its ruling, the ASA, which is the U.K. equivalent of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), sided with NDC, stating that the ads did not make it clear that the diamonds were lab grown.
It also said the above terms were misleading, and the ads breached the U.K. Code of Non-Broadcast Advertising, Sales Promotion and Direct Marketing rules 3.1 and 3.3, with regards to misleading advertising, and 3.9, with regards to qualification.
The code states, “marketing communications must not mislead the consumer by omitting material information. They must not mislead by hiding material information or presenting it in an unclear, unintelligible, ambiguous, or untimely manner.”
All of Skydiamond’s ads included clear gemstones and references to diamonds, the ruling said, and it considered consumers would understand “diamond” in insolation to mean a naturally occurring mineral of crystallized carbon.
While some consumers would be aware that diamonds could be manufactured in a lab, ASA said, many would not.
ASA directed Skydiamond not to use the above terms to describe their lab-grown diamonds without a clear and prominent qualifier, such as “synthetic,” “laboratory-grown” or “laboratory-created,” or another way of conveying the same meaning to consumers in a direct and obvious manner.
It also told the retailer the ads must not appear again in the form complained about, and to not use the claim “real diamonds” to describe lab-grown diamonds.
Skydiamond said it plans to appeal the ruling, calling it “a mistake.”
“Our website and all of our marketing, indeed our very name, make clear that our diamonds come from the sky, we make them or mine them from the sky," said Dale Vince, founder of Skydiamond.
"We make that very clear. Nobody could possibly think they are conventional stones ripped from the bowels of the earth at enormous environmental cost, and nobody actually has. This complaint is not based on actual confusion on the part of customer; it comes from the trade body for diamond mining companies, [and] it is an attempt to use the ASA for anti-competitive purposes and it utterly baseless."
The NDC, which filed in March 2023, based its complaint on the Diamond Terminology Guideline, a reference document that, as of 2020, is assured and recognized by Trading Standards in the U.K. market.
The U.K.’s National Association of Jewellers, along with leading industry organizations, have endorsed the guideline, which is built on the ISO 18323 Standard (“Jewellery – Consumer confidence in the diamond industry”) and the CIBJO Diamond Blue Book.
The FTC has its own rules on diamond terminology, but it is not recognized for diamonds sold outside the United States.
The Diamond Terminology Guideline states that all documents, websites, and other means of communication intended to sell, buy, and promote natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, gemstones, lab reports, and natural and lab-grown diamond jewelry must use “synthetic,” “laboratory-grown” or “laboratory-created” when referring to lab-grown diamonds, a directive the ASA references in its ruling.
In one section of its lengthy response to NDC’s complaint, Skydiamond called the guideline a tool that “should not be, and did not profess to be, the only basis for defining the origin of a diamond or for determining definitively whether diamond ads were misleading to an average consumer.”
Skydiamond also argued that of the 23 steps in its “novel and innovative” production process, only the CVD step was shared with conventional lab-grown diamond production processes, and commercialization of its process post-dated the introduction of the Diamond Terminology Guideline, so it was not considered for inclusion.
The ASA acknowledged in its ruling that the guideline had been updated in 2023, but there were no major changes to the 2020 version.
And, although it agrees Skydiamond’s production process differs from other diamond growers, ASA said the diamonds were lab grown nonetheless and consumers needed to know that before making a transactional decision.
The NDC’s complaint to the ASA regarding misleading terminology in advertisements for lab-grown diamonds initially included three other U.K. retailers—Stephen Webster, Lark & Berry, and Idyl.
According to NDC, ASA dropped its case against Stephen Webster but did note that its ruling in the Skydiamond case also applies to Stephen Webster’s marketing and communications.
A spokesperson for Stephen Webster said the company had no comment on the ruling.
The ASA investigated ads from the other two retailers and considered them to be in breach of code—Lark & Berry for the use of “cultured diamond” and “diamond” without a qualifier when referring to synthetic diamonds, and Idyl for the use of the terms “diamonds,” “diamond sparkle,” “fine diamond jewelry,” “sustainable diamonds,” and “Diamonds of the Future” in the same context.
Lark & Berry agreed to amend the ads with qualifiers such as “synthetic,” “laboratory-grown,” and “laboratory-created.”
Idyl also agreed to amend their advertisements that targeted U.K. consumers.
Both rulings have been published as informally resolved on ASA’s website.
The Latest
The “Tiffany Céleste” collection reimagines designer Jean Schlumberger’s interpretations of the universe.
The brand also created a 100-carat lab-grown diamond necklace in honor of its centennial.
Tim Schlick has been promoted from his previous position as COO.
Meet Ben Claus—grand prize winner of For the Love of Jewelers 2023 Fall Design Challenge.
It’s the second year for the event, slated to take place in October in Toronto.
Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA
Sales will be paused while the relocation takes place over the next few months.
With Ho Brothers, you can unlock your brand's true potential and offer customers the personalized jewelry experiences they desire.
“SIS x MISA Denim and Diamonds” is a collaboration between the designer and celebrity stylist Misa Hylton.
The retailer is moving to a newly designed space in the same shopping center.
Gifts that are unique and thoughtful are top of mind this year, according to the annual survey.
The necklace is featured in the brand’s “Rebel Heart” campaign starring Adam Levine and Behati Prinsloo.
The two organizations will host a joint event, “Converge,” in September 2025.
Big changes appear to be on the horizon for the diamond miner and its parent company, Anglo American.
Padis succeeds Lisa Bridge, marking the first time the organization has had two women board presidents in a row.
Jesse Cole, founder of Fans First Entertainment, shared the “five Es” of building a fan base during his AGS Conclave keynote.
The Royal Oak Perpetual Calendar "John Mayer" was celebrated at a star-studded party in LA last week.
The announcement came as the company reported a 23 percent drop in production in Q1.
The three-time Pro Bowler continues to partner with the retailer, donating to a Detroit nonprofit and giving watches to fans.
A double-digit drop in the number of in-store crimes was offset by a jump in off-premises attacks, JSA’s 2023 crime report shows.
Inspired by the Roman goddess of love, the designer looked to the sea for her new collection.
The luxury titan posted declining sales, weighed down by Gucci’s poor performance.
The selected nine organizations have outlined their plans for the funds.
The mining company’s Diavik Diamond Mine lost four employees in a plane crash in January.
The crown introduced a dozen timepieces in Geneva, including a heavy metal version of its deep-sea divers’ watch.
Emmanuel Raheb recommends digging into demographic data, customizing your store’s communications, and retargeting ahead of May 12.
Located in the town of Queensbury, it features a dedicated bridal section and a Gabriel & Co. store-in-store.