Majors

Signet-Zale: The culmination of consolidation

MajorsAug 30, 2018

Signet-Zale: The culmination of consolidation

National Jeweler analyzes the price tag on the $1.4 billion deal between Signet Jewelers and Zale Corp., what it means for the jewelry industry as a whole and what the real “pickup” of the acquisition is for Signet.

New York--Flipping through National Jeweler’s last few State of the Majors lists tells a tale of an industry that is continuing to shrink. 


Friedman’s, Whitehall Jewelers and Finlay Fine Jewelry, once mainstays on the list of $100 Million Supersellers, have been out of the game for several years. Ultra Stores Inc. is now part of Signet Jewelers Ltd. while other players that remain on the list--think J.C. Penney and Sears/Kmart--are grappling with serious problems.

Now, the two largest U.S. jewelers in terms of store count, Signet and Zale Corp., are on track to become one, in what industry analyst and consultant Ben Janowski calls the culmination of a string of consolidations that began back in the 1980s.

“Who was going to buy them (Zale)? The only reasonable, logical buyer was Signet all along, and that’s been rumored for ages,” he said. “That’s the track that has been going on in terms of mall consolidation for a long time and this is the culmination. There’s not much left.”

Zale essentially was the second-place finisher in what, over the years, had become a one-horse race in the thinned-out field of mall jewelers.

The Signet-Zale situation is comparable to the rivalries between Bed, Bath & Beyond and Linens ‘n Things, or Circuit City and Best Buy. As retail evolved, there was only room for one big player in each of those respective markets.

The only difference is “Zale was smarter about it,” said Consensus Advisors President Chris Ellis, who has handled a number of transactions in the jewelry industry.

Aided by a $150 million lifeline extended by private equity firm Golden Gate Capital in 2010, Zale battled back from the brink of bankruptcy by shuttering failing stores, introducing fresh, proprietary brands such as Love by Vera Wang bridal, and forging a presence for itself on social media.

RELATED CONTENT: Zale gains liquidity, gets $150M from investors

While Linens ‘n Things ended up online-only and Circuit City is out of business entirely, Signet paid $21 per share in the deal announced Wednesday for Zale, a retailer whose shares had once traded below $2.

“That was a pretty impressive recovery. That’s (something) to give them credit for,” Ellis said.

For Signet, the merger essentially was the only way to the top in a mature industry where growth opportunities are minimal.

“They want to be the largest and most profitable jewelry retailer

in the world, and this is a good way to do it,” Ellis said. “They were a powerhouse and they are now, overnight, becoming an even more dominant player.”

By the numbers
The number $690 million was widely reported as the purchase price for Zale when news of the deal broke Wednesday morning. That figure later was revised upward to $900 million.

However, when factoring in the warrants owned by private equity firm Golden Gate Capital, which has a 22 percent stake in Zale, and Zale’s debt, the deal is valued at a total of $1.4 billion.

Janowski said when it’s broken down, the $1.4 billion price tag adds up to a deal for Signet.

The purchase price is well less than $1 million per store, especially when factoring in the online operations and accounting for the fact that Zale’s store count of 1,679 includes 624 Piercing Pagoda kiosks, which are not full-line jewelry stores.

He said when Sterling Jewelers was gobbling up smaller chains in the 1980s and 1990s, the typical price was $1 million a store, which would be much more in today’s dollars. “When you are buying something like this and it’s, give or take, $1 million a store, you are paying as much as you did with much better dollars than you did 25 years ago.

“This whole business has not gone very far. In fact, it’s gone down. It’s an indication that Zale finally had to make some kind of move. They were not getting out of the morass that they were in.”

Before the merger is final, the deal has to be approved by regulators and Zale’s shareholders.

If it goes through, the transaction will merge the two largest jewelry chains in the United States, creating a chain of more than 3,600 stores in the U.S., Canada and the United Kingdom that generate more than $6 billion in annual sales and employ close to 30,000. Stores operating under this umbrella will include well-known brands such as Zales, Piercing Pagoda, Kay Jewelers, Jared the Galleria of Jewelry and Peoples Jewellers in Canada.

In a presentation given Wednesday morning, Signet said the combination creates a “more diversified” retailer with a total of 3,653 stores in three countries. It said it plans to invest in and grow Zales’ brands, while operating them as a standalone portfolio within Signet, with CEO Theo Killion still at the helm.

Analysts, however, say that the chain won’t remain at 3,653 stores for the long term.

Ellis says eventually there will be consolidation in markets where there is duplication.

In some cases, the company may opt to keep multiple stores open in the same market because it works. “(But) it doesn’t work everywhere,” he said. “If there was no consolidation, there would be no point in making the acquisition, would there?

“I think it’s a pretty safe to assume you are not going to have Kay and Zales in the same mall.”

Janowski agrees, adding that while the further consolidation of the mall jewelry business could have a positive impact on other mall jewelers that may have one less competitor, it won’t mean much for independents, many of whom long ago abandoned the malls’ halls.

“You are not going to see duplication of efforts in the same market,” he said. “I think Canada is the big pickup (in this deal.)”

The potential acquisition of Zale gives Signet a foothold of 199 Peoples and Mappins stores in Canada, a market where it previously had no stores, as well as approximately 125 Zales Outlet stores in the U.S. and Puerto Rico, a space in which Signet has been keen on expanding recently.

RELATED STORY: Sterling completes $57M Ultra acquisition

The company’s last big acquisition, completed in November 2012, was of Ultra Stores Inc., operator of Ultra Diamonds outlets, which it is converting into Kay Outlet stores.

Who’s next?
Signet’s 2012 acquisition of the Ultra stores was followed by Swatch Group’s $1 billion purchase of the Harry Winston name and retail chain from Harry Winston Diamond Corp. in 2013. The company formerly known as Harry Winston Diamond Corp. is now Dominion Diamond Corp. and its sole business is diamond mining.

RELATED CONTENT: Swatch buys Harry Winston retail

While there has been plenty of consolidation at the manufacturing end of the business, neither Janowski nor Ellis could give a solid prediction as to what the next major retail merger might be in the U.S. market.

“I don’t think in retail there is anything that leaps off the page at me,” Ellis said. “I think there will be a lot of activity further up the supply chain.”

New York-based retailer Tiffany & Co. has been mentioned as a prime acquisition target for one of the world’s luxury goods conglomerates, such as LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton, which snapped up Bulgari in 2011, or Kering (formerly PPR), which bought a majority stake in Pomellato last year.

Janowski said the brand recognition the 177-year-old retailer garners is enough to make the conglomerates “salivate” at the thought of acquiring Tiffany. None of the other big jewelry stores lining the tony stretch of Fifth Avenue just south of Central Park--Bulgari, Wempe, Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels--have the same draw as the Tiffany store, he said.

“Who knows?” if Tiffany will be acquired one day, Janowski said. “It’s almost impossible to predict that. Certainly they have said no to all those possible inquiries that have come up in the past.”

But that doesn’t mean, at some point, a company won’t make the venerable retailer an offer it simply can’t refuse, he added. “There’s no way to know that."

Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

Future Fortune sapphire ring
TechnologyMar 28, 2024
Pinterest’s 2024 Wedding Report Is Out

The report shows that couples are searching for vintage and antique rings, gold jewelry, pearls, and colorful pieces.

David Ettinger
IndependentsMar 28, 2024
David Ettinger of Bechdel Jewelers Dies at 69

He’s remembered as a “font of passion,” leaving behind a legacy of dedication to his craft and community.

Jewelers of America logo
IndependentsMar 28, 2024
JA to Host Series of Learning Workshops

The first one will take place next month during the Jewelers of Louisiana’s and Mississippi Jewelers Association’s conventions.

Jewelers of America Fly In Washington, D.C.
Brought to you by
How Jewelers of America Represents Your Business

For over 30 years, JA has advocated for the industry, fought against harmful legislation and backed measures that help jewelry businesses.

Jaeger-LeCoultre Madison Avenue NYC store
WatchesMar 28, 2024
Peek Inside Jaeger-LeCoultre’s Revamped NYC Flagship

The redesigned boutique features interactive displays and a workshop space for hands-on learning about watchmaking.

Weekly QuizMar 28, 2024
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge with this short test.
Take the Quiz
Asian Star’s diamond manufacturing facility in India
SourcingMar 27, 2024
Compliance, Caution, and Concern: The Current Outlook of Indian Diamantaires

There is a willingness to comply with new government-mandated regulations, with an insistence that they should be practical and realistic.

Kira Diam solar plant
Lab-GrownMar 27, 2024
Indian Lab-Grown Diamond Manufacturers Keep Growing

A combination of factors is driving growth in the industry despite the precipitous drop in prices across the board.

BTYB-HoBrothers-updated.png
Brought to you by
The Scalable, Professional, and Effortless Solution for High-Demand Custom Jewelry Retailers

Ho Brothers offers scalable solutions for the future of custom jewelry.

Bharat Ratnam, a Mega Common Facilitation Centre (CFC)
SourcingMar 27, 2024
Reinvigorating SEEPZ, the Epicenter of India’s Studded Jewelry Exports

The zone’s modernization will enhance and increase India’s jewelry manufacturing capabilities while aiding small and mid-sized businesses.

SRK Empire and SRK House
Policies & IssuesMar 27, 2024
SRK Exports’ Journey Toward Net Zero Impact

By the end of this year, SRK’s diamond manufacturing complexes will achieve net zero emissions, one of an impressive array of achievements.

Georgia May Jagger Tommy Hilfiger ad campaign
FinancialsMar 27, 2024
Movado’s Full-Year Sales Sink 11%

The company plans to invest $25 million in marketing initiatives to boost awareness around its namesake and licensed brands.

Hand holding shopping bags
SurveysMar 27, 2024
Consumer Confidence Held Steady in March

Optimism about the current state of the economy was offset by anxiety around inflation and the political environment.

Bernadette Mack
Policies & IssuesMar 27, 2024
Mercury Free Mining Hires Bernadette Mack

The former WJA executive director is MFM’s new managing director.

April Is Diamonds Do Good Month
Policies & IssuesMar 27, 2024
Diamonds Do Good Announces Its April Initiative

DDG encourages retailers to educate customers on the positive impact of purchasing natural diamonds.

National Jeweler columnists Duvall O’Steen and Jen Cullen Williams
ColumnistsMar 26, 2024
Creative Connecting: AI Tools and Tips for Social Media

Jen Cullen Williams and Duvall O’Steen explore how jewelers can save time and money by using AI to analyze engagement and create content.

Interior of Miami Lakes Jewelers
IndependentsMar 26, 2024
Miami Lakes Jewelers to Close After 37 Years

The Florida store’s owner Miguel Gonzalez is retiring.

 International Gemological Institute
GradingMar 26, 2024
IGI Announces Tech for ID’ing Lab-Grown Colored Diamonds

The lab stresses the importance of accurate identification, as the difference in price is “substantial.”

Kendra Scott lab-grown diamond jewelry
CollectionsMar 25, 2024
Kendra Scott Debuts Lab-Grown Diamond Fashion Jewelry

The brand also plans to expand its retail footprint from 138 to 200 stores over the next three years.

Instappraise logo NAJA logo
Events & AwardsMar 25, 2024
NAJA, Instappraise Offering Scholarships for Aspiring Jewelry Appraisers

One is reserved for a NAJA member, the other for a non-member.

Carie Lehrke and Megan Mattice
MajorsMar 25, 2024
Borsheims Announces New VP of HR, Assistant Manager

Longtime employees Carie Lehrke and Megan Mattice have received promotions.

My Next Question graphic vintage jewelry webinar
Recorded WebinarsMar 22, 2024
Watch: How to Buy and Sell Vintage Jewelry

Three guests joined National Jeweler and Jewelers of America to discuss trending time periods, spotting reproductions, and more.

Chris Clipper and Robert Lepere
MajorsMar 22, 2024
David Yurman Announces New CFO, Chief People Officer

Chris Clipper and Robert Lepere join the company with 50 years of combined experience.

Nakard pyrite earrings
CollectionsMar 22, 2024
Piece of the Week: Nakard’s Pyrite Earrings

The trendy, metallic earrings wink at classic spring colors.

Stock image of police cars with their lights on
CrimeMar 21, 2024
Sparks Fly as Burglars Lose Safe on California Freeway

JSA said a man and woman pulled the safe out of an Oakland jewelry store but couldn’t quite get it into their van.

Grizzly Mining rough emeralds
SourcingMar 21, 2024
Grizzly Sells 4,145-Carat Emerald for Over $1M

The miner’s March auction generated $19 million.

Helen McCluskey
MajorsMar 21, 2024
Signet Jewelers Names New Board Chair

Helen McCluskey will succeed H. Todd Stitzer when he meets his 12-year term limit in June.

Julia Roberts wearing a Chopard necklace
CollectionsMar 20, 2024
Julia Roberts Co-Designs New Chopard Jewelry Collection

“Chopard x Julia Roberts” showcases the first gems cut from the 6,000-carat-plus “Insofu Emerald."

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy