Editors

5 Tips for Buying Antique and Estate Jewelry

EditorsFeb 14, 2018

5 Tips for Buying Antique and Estate Jewelry

Dealers at The Original Miami Beach Antique Show dish on the telltale signs that something is a reproduction and the importance of experience.

The author modeling a silver and blister pearl necklace created by The Kalo Shop in Chicago that is part of the personal collection of Kalo collector and Jewelry History Series presenter John P. Walcher.

Last week I was in Miami for The Original Miami Beach Antique Show and the following happened, in this order:

--I gave a talk on the history behind the squash blossom necklace at the Jewelry History Series with minimal heckling;

--I heard a number of other informative presentations, including one on World War II “Sweetheart Jewelry” by Jan Krulick and another from John P. Walcher of Chicago auction house Toomey & Co. on the jewelry made in the Windy City during the Arts & Crafts movement, particularly at The Kalo Shop;

--I saw some incredible jewelry (some of which is pictured here) and made great new friends; and

--I dipped my toes in the Atlantic Ocean (translation: I attempted to get only my feet wet but underestimated the waves and ended up with jeans soaked to the knees.)

Along the way, I stopped to chat with dealers at the show to get their advice on antique and estate jewelry buying for those who are opening a store (brick-and-mortar or online), taking over the buying responsibilities at an established store or looking to get into the business.

The advice I heard repeated most often wasn’t so much advice as it was a statement of fact: second-hand buying is mainly about experience. Being a good buyer comes from years of looking at and handling jewelry and, as with anything else, making mistakes along the way.

“The more you handle, the better you get,” New York-based dealer Hartley Brown told me at his booth while allowing me to handle some beautiful mandarin garnets. “It’s experience.”

And when I stopped by the booth of Kurt Rother of Los Angeles-based Excalibur on Saturday afternoon and asked him how to tell if a piece of allegedly antique jewelry is a reproduction, he summed it up like this: “years of experience.”   

There were, however, a few specific tips that I was able to glean from the dealers I spoke with in Miami.

1. Examine the jewelry from all angles, carefully.
Look at the back of a piece of jewelry, Brown advised, not just the front. Good antique jewelry will be expertly finished but, as we will get to under No. 2, not without signs of wear.

Diane Richardson of The Gold Hatpin in Oak Park, Illinois, said to always examine a piece of jewelry with a loupe before buying—look at the stamp, check the findings, check the prongs.

And looks for chips in gemstones and cracks in enamel, which is especially difficult to repair, said Mitch Weisz, who runs Crystal Lake, Illinois-based Ameritiques Ltd. with his wife, Marcia. At his booth, he pointed out a chipped gemstone in a ring that he had overlooked and was pointed out to him by a potential buyer who took a loupe to the piece.

When possible, Richardson said, try on the jewelry to see if its lays right and is comfortable. “If something doesn’t work, factor that into negotiating the price,” she said.

2. If it’s old, it should look it.
While Rother’s immediate answer to my question about spotting reproductions was “experience,” he did allow that there are a few obvious signs that a piece is not as old as advertised, chief among them being no signs of wear.

If, for example, there are loops connecting two gemstones in an earring, there should be a small groove where the loops connect. Pointing to the necklace I was wearing that day, a gold medallion passed down to me by my grandmother, he noted that I would see the same on the bail.

Khan Ismael, an independent British dealer working at the booth of Lowther Antiques, said to check the prongs to see if they show signs of wear and, also, to look at the enamel. If a piece of jewelry is supposed to be 200 years old and the enamel is pristine, then something is off.

He added that weight and size also are good indicators of age.

A lot of older jewelry—Georgian chain, for example—was very light.

Antique cuffs are often small because people had smaller wrists, while antique rings tend to the extremes.

They are either small (because, again, people were smaller) or large because they were made to be worn over gloves. It is unusual, he said, to be able to get antique rings in the average rings sizes of today, like a 6 or a 7.

3. Money, money, money.
I received a few tips regarding price, starting with this one from Ismael, who is widely known (as I discovered many at the people at this show are) by his Instagram handle, @ishyantiques: “If something seems too good to be true, it probably is.”

Ismael said buyers have to think logically when they are shopping and not get swept up in a piece; if the price seems too low, there is probably a reason for it.

Richardson, along with Walcher, of Toomey & Co., advised shopping around to compare and contrast the items and prices available at the various booths.

Walcher added this, which I think is solid advice for shopping anywhere: “Don’t buy the first thing you see, unless you know you can’t live without it and believe it to be a fair price. Nothing is worse than buyer’s remorse.”

4. Use outside resources.
Richardson recommended reading up on antique jewelry before buying. Lang’s online Antique Jewelry University is not a bad place to start, and I learned of a website at the show dedicated entirely to mourning jewelry, ArtofMourning.com.

Walcher advised bringing along someone more experienced while Rother, whose family was not in the jewelry business, learned from others along the way: “If someone was willing to tell me something, I was willing to listen.”


A 14-karat gold horseshoe ring set with peridot, amethyst, sapphires and diamonds purchased for the author’s personal collection from The Gold Hatpin. The ring is from the ‘70s or ‘80s

5. Buy what you love … or don’t.
This last bit of advice was interesting to me, as it seems to go against what retailers are advised to do when buying new jewelry, which is: buy what is selling in the store, not what appeals to you personally.

The dealers at the show, however, argued that with antique and estate pieces, it’s different. It’s not the same as filling in gaps in pre-made lines and collections. It’s about finding pieces you are passionate about because that passion will come through to your customers.

“People start out, often, buying what is popular, but if you buy what you like, you can be enthusiastic about selling it,” Richardson said.

Mitch Weisz also advised buying what you like, noting “If you think it’s wonderful, then customers will too.”

And Ismael offered this, which I would advise practicing with some measure of restraint: “Buy what you like because if you don’t sell it, you can keep it.”

I asked a retailer about this, Ron Samuelson of Samuelson’s Diamonds, who attended the Miami show with his store’s new director of estate jewelry, Allie Lopato.

He said while he can see the intrinsic value in older items, he doesn’t advise buying estate and antique jewelry based on personal taste. Instead, he recommends checking inventory data to see what’s selling, just as you would for new lines.

“You buy something you love, but is everyone else going really going to love it?” he asked. “Everybody has inventory issues. Whether it’s secondhand or not, you don’t want to get stuck with an item that you really loved that not everyone else loved.”
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

SourcingAug 05, 2022
Rare Earth Mining Co.’s Bill Heher Dies at 72

The passionate gem lover helped bring more than 300 different varieties of stones to the gem trade.

TrendsAug 05, 2022
Piece of the Week: Storrow Jewelry’s ‘Emblem Rosa’ Charm

The brand has attracted attention for its colorful, vintage-inspired pieces.

MajorsAug 05, 2022
Former Nike Executive Joins Team at David Yurman

Marcelo Tau is the company’s new chief operations officer.

Brought to you by
The American Mined™ Collection: Ethical Sourcing That Matters

Rio Grande provides a pathway to responsibly sourced gemstones.

Policies & IssuesAug 05, 2022
Satta Matturi Joins RJC Board

The jewelry designer founded her eponymous brand in 2015 after nearly two decades in the diamond industry.

Weekly QuizAug 04, 2022
This Week’s Quiz
Test your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
Take the Quiz
Supplier BulletinAug 04, 2022
Unusual Jewelry Finds Eager Buyers In Online Auctions

Sponsored by HiBid

WatchesAug 04, 2022
4 Takeaways from Chrono24’s Analysis of the Luxury Watch Market

The watch seller comments on future demand, how the crypto crash impacted Rolex and Patek Philippe pricing, the supply recovery, and more.

Brought to you by
Knowledge and Skills for Today’s Hot Topics

From laboratory-grown diamonds to design to country-of-origin, GIA's Alumni Collective™ has a seminar to suite your needs.

CollectionsAug 04, 2022
The Rest of De Beers’ 2022 High Jewelry Collection Is Here

It features fives sets of jewelry.

Lab-GrownAug 04, 2022
Lab-Grown Diamond Co. Plasmability Partners with HRA Group

Through the collaboration, HRA will exclusively cut, polish, and distribute Plasmability’s lab-grown diamonds in the market.

IndependentsAug 04, 2022
TJA to Offer ‘Texas Tours’ at Upcoming Round-Up Event

They include a tour of a museum’s gem collection and demonstrations of diamond cutting and polishing.

TechnologyAug 03, 2022
Tiffany Introduces CryptoPunk NFT Pendants

The limited-edition pendants, available in digital and physical form, retail for $50,000 and are exclusive to holders of CryptoPunks NFTs.

AuctionsAug 03, 2022
Elvis and Colonel Tom Parker’s ‘Lost’ Jewelry Coming to Auction

The sale includes pieces “The King” gifted to his longtime manager, as well as jewelry Elvis owned and wore on stage.

WatchesAug 03, 2022
Breitling’s Latest Ambassador Is an NFL Star

Trevor Lawrence is the quarterback for the Jacksonville Jaguars.

SourcingAug 03, 2022
Gembridge Launches Reseller Program for Colored Stones and Jewelry

It gives trade members full access to its catalog of products so they can sell listings on their own online platforms.

IndependentsAug 03, 2022
Day’s Jewelers Announces New VP of Merchandising

Julie Collins succeeds Kathy Corey in the role.

ColumnistsAug 02, 2022
Why Passing on Lab-Grown Diamonds Might Be a Risky Bet

Retailers would be wise to embrace this growing segment of the market instead of shunning it, Peter Smith writes.

SourcingAug 02, 2022
AGTA Names John Ford as Its New CEO

He’s the owner of The Lightning Ridge Collection but will pivot to focus on his new role.

TrendsAug 02, 2022
Marvel Debuts Gem-Set Infinity Gauntlet

East Continental Gems provided more than 150 carats of gemstones for the project.

SurveysAug 02, 2022
Consumer Confidence Falls for Third Month in July

Rising prices and interest rate hikes are expected to weigh on consumer spending and economic growth over the next six months.

TrendsAug 01, 2022
Amanda’s Style File: Peridot That Pops

To kick off August, Amanda Gizzi is sharing jewelry featuring the month’s OG birthstone.

CrimeAug 01, 2022
Joseph DuMouchelle Sentenced to 12 Years Behind Bars in $12M Fraud

The Michigan auctioneer and appraiser also has to pay restitution totaling $25 million for other victims of his fraud scheme.

MajorsAug 01, 2022
GIA Appoints First Vice President of Sustainability Programs

Johanna Levy will oversee the environmental, social, and governance programs.

SourcingJul 29, 2022
De Beers Sales Rise 23% YOY in July

Despite unusually high summertime sales, the company’s CEO said the industry remains “watchful.”

MajorsJul 29, 2022
Jewelers of America Elects 4 New Directors to Board

Joseph Corey, Krystle Craycraft, Sue Hopeman, and Sherry Smith will each serve three-year terms on the board.

TrendsJul 29, 2022
Piece of the Week: Zahn-Z Jewelry’s ‘Gem Pop’ Ring

A lab-grown ruby makes the perfect nostalgic treat.

Supplier BulletinJul 28, 2022
Local Jewelry Dealers Use Online Auctions To Find Bidders Worldwide

Sponsored by HiBid

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy