IndependentsMay 10, 2024
Frank Adams Jewelers Names New CEOKimberly Adams Russell is taking over the role from her father, David Adams, marking the third generation to hold the title.
TechnologyOct 14, 2013
Brands win injunction in cyber counterfeiting case
Six brands under the Richemont Group umbrella recently scored a victory in what their attorney is calling a “landmark” case in the ongoing battle against an online sale of counterfeit luxury goods.
Los Angeles--Six brands under the Richemont Group umbrella recently scored a victory in what their attorney is calling a “landmark” case in the ongoing battle against the online sale of counterfeit luxury goods.
In a ruling dated Oct. 8, a judge in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California issued a summary judgment and permanent injunction against Saudi Arabia-based Sawabeh Information Services Co. (SISCOM) and Pakistan-based TradeKey (Pvt.) Ltd. effectively barring SISCOM-owned websites from selling merchandise bearing the Cartier, Montblanc, Panerai, A. Lange & Söhne, Chloè and Alfred Dunhill trademarks.
The brands’ attorney Susan M. Kayser, a partner at Jones Day in Washington, said the ruling is significant because, in the past, defendants in these types of cases argued that they couldn’t be held liable for counterfeit goods sold on their sites unless they received notice of a specific infringing listing.
One of the most well-known cases in this arena was the lengthy legal battle between Tiffany & Co. and online auction site eBay, a case in which the courts eventually ruled that eBay was not responsible for trademark violations when its users sold counterfeit Tiffany merchandise via the site.
“Our position was, you have knowledge,” Kayser said. “You have knowledge because you are aware of what’s going on on your website. You are allowing and facilitating these counterfeiters on this site and this can’t be allowed. You have to take responsibility for what’s on your website.”
“This is very different from Tiffany v. eBay. We think it’s a big victory for brand owners and consumers."
However, SISCOM’s attorney, Erik Syverson at Miller Barondess LLP in Los Angeles, said he and his clients completely disagree with the court’s ruling and, in their eyes, the case is not settled. He said they “considering all options” going forward.
“Followed to its logical conclusion, this ruling requires websites that permit user-generated advertising to proactively screen for infringing or counterfeit items listed for sale. That is not the law. The law has always required that trademark owners perform such a function,” he said.
According to court papers filed in the case, SISCOM owns TradeKey.com and the mirror sites SaudiCommerce.com and B2BFreeZone.com. These sites function as business-to-business websites that solicit wholesale buyers and sellers worldwide to become paying members and then help them to sell products en masse.
Tipped off by what Kayser described as the “pure magnitude” of
the operation, the Richemont Group brands first filed suit against SISCOM and TradeKey in 2011, as well as against 18 individual TradeKey member sellers.
Though none of the 18 individual sellers ever answered the complaint or appeared in court, the court granted a default judgment against these sellers in April 2012, granting “very broad” injunctive relief that prevented them from using the trademarks in any listing, forcing them to turn over their domain names and granting the brands a monetary award, said Kayser.
From there, she said the Richemont labels pursued their case against SISCOM and TradeKey.
According to court papers, an investigator hired by the brands found more than 6,000 sellers offering branded products on TradeKey.com, including more than 850 offering Panerai-branded goods, 500 selling Montblanc, 1,900 offering Cartier and at least two premium members with A. Lange & Söhne-branded goods.
None of the sellers were authorized by these companies to sell genuine goods bearing their trademarks, court papers state. In addition, the investigator actually purchased five Panerai, two Montblanc and four Cartier watches from a variety of sellers on TradeKey.com, and each of the brands confirmed that these products were fakes.
As of Monday afternoon, watches and jewelry under the trademarks Cartier, A. Lange & Söhne, Montblanc and Panerai appeared to have been removed from the sites.
A search for products under those brand names pulled up either blank pages or a message that read “This page has been permanently removed!” and a link to a Product Posting Policy.
While the court issued a permanent injunction and summary judgment, the judge deferred issuing any kind of monetary award in the case.
Kayser said they plan to move separately for damages at a later time. “The big thing here is we got incredibly broad injunctive relief, which is what the client wants,” she said.
Though none of the 18 individual sellers ever answered the complaint or appeared in court, the court granted a default judgment against these sellers in April 2012, granting “very broad” injunctive relief that prevented them from using the trademarks in any listing, forcing them to turn over their domain names and granting the brands a monetary award, said Kayser.
From there, she said the Richemont labels pursued their case against SISCOM and TradeKey.
According to court papers, an investigator hired by the brands found more than 6,000 sellers offering branded products on TradeKey.com, including more than 850 offering Panerai-branded goods, 500 selling Montblanc, 1,900 offering Cartier and at least two premium members with A. Lange & Söhne-branded goods.
None of the sellers were authorized by these companies to sell genuine goods bearing their trademarks, court papers state. In addition, the investigator actually purchased five Panerai, two Montblanc and four Cartier watches from a variety of sellers on TradeKey.com, and each of the brands confirmed that these products were fakes.
As of Monday afternoon, watches and jewelry under the trademarks Cartier, A. Lange & Söhne, Montblanc and Panerai appeared to have been removed from the sites.
A search for products under those brand names pulled up either blank pages or a message that read “This page has been permanently removed!” and a link to a Product Posting Policy.
While the court issued a permanent injunction and summary judgment, the judge deferred issuing any kind of monetary award in the case.
Kayser said they plan to move separately for damages at a later time. “The big thing here is we got incredibly broad injunctive relief, which is what the client wants,” she said.
More on Technology
The Latest
CollectionsMay 10, 2024
Piece of the Week: Carina Hardy’s ‘Birth of Venus’ NecklaceAs a token of womanhood, this necklace depicts when Venus was born from the sea.
MajorsMay 09, 2024
Watches of Switzerland Pays $130M for Roberto Coin Inc.The deal gives the retailer control over the distribution of Roberto Coin jewelry in the U.S., Canada, Caribbean, and Central America.
Brought to you by
From Registration to Return: 10 Tips to Protect You Before, During and After a TradeshowTradeshow risks are real. Get tips to protect yourself before, during and after and gain safety and security awareness for your business.
TrendsMay 09, 2024
Amanda’s Style File: Shine Bright, Moms Show your mother some love with a piece of fine jewelry.
Weekly QuizMay 09, 2024
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these seven questions.
IndependentsMay 09, 2024
Kyle Edward Fine Jewelry to Close Salisbury StoreThe company’s Easton location will remain open.
MajorsMay 09, 2024
JBT Elects New ChairmanBrian D. Fleming of Carla Corporation was elected to serve a one-year term in the role.
Brought to you by
Rio’s Reimagined Podcast: For the Love of JewelersMeet Ben Claus—grand prize winner of For the Love of Jewelers 2023 Fall Design Challenge.
Supplier BulletinMay 08, 2024
Fusing Past and Present at the Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch ShowSponsored by the Las Vegas Antique Jewelry and Watch Show
EditorsMay 07, 2024
Q&A: Author Vikki Tobak on the ‘Ice-Cold’ ExhibitionTobak, author of “Ice Cold: A Hip-Hop Jewelry History,” shares how the exhibition came to be, and the pieces people may be surprised to see.
EditorsMay 07, 2024
10 On-Theme Looks from the 2024 Met GalaStars adorned themselves in emeralds, platinum, and myriad bird motifs, writes Associate Editor Natalie Francisco.
IndependentsMay 07, 2024
112-Year-Old New Orleans Business Popping Up in Aspen M.S. Rau is set to open a seasonal gallery in the high-end resort town early next month.
MajorsMay 07, 2024
Richemont Acquires Italian Jeweler VhernierThe branded jewelry market is thriving, said Richemont Chairman Johann Rupert.
CollectionsMay 07, 2024
These ‘Luminaries’ Are Set to Light Up CoutureThe six designers, all participants in the show’s Diversity Action Council mentorship program, will exhibit in Salon 634.
AuctionsMay 07, 2024
Sotheby’s to Auction Sylvester Stallone’s WatchesThe highlight of his collection is the coveted Patek Philippe Grandmaster Chime, which could sell for up to $5 million.
CollectionsMay 07, 2024
Phillip Gavriel Pays Tribute to Venice With New CollectionThe “Venetian Link” series modernizes the classic Veneziana box chain in its bracelets and necklaces.
Events & AwardsMay 07, 2024
JA Now Accepting Applications for New Bench Jeweler ScholarshipThe Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship will provide tuition assistance to two low-income students.
Policies & IssuesMay 06, 2024
Rolex Files Objection to Hallmark’s New Trademark ApplicationThe Swiss watchmaker said the company’s plans to use a new version of the Hallmark crown on jewelry would confuse consumers.
EditorsMay 06, 2024
Q&A: 8 Questions With Anglo American’s Benny Oeyen The executive talked about the importance of self-purchasers and how fuel cell electric vehicles are going to fuel demand for platinum.
MajorsMay 06, 2024
Malabar Gold & Diamonds Opens 4th U.S. ShowroomThe Indian jeweler’s new store in Naperville, Illinois marks its 350th location, part of its ongoing global expansion plans.
Events & AwardsMay 06, 2024
Ben Bridge Jeweler Accepting Applications for Lonia Tate ScholarshipIt will award a graduating high school student with about $10,000 toward a GIA diploma and an internship with the Seattle-based jeweler.
CrimeMay 03, 2024
Second Suspect Arrested in Murder of Colorado JewelerWheat Ridge, Colorado police took a 50-year-old man into custody Wednesday following a two-month search.
CollectionsMay 03, 2024
A Sneak Peek Into PGI’s Couture Platinum Spotlight ProgramPGI partnered with four new and seven returning designers for its annual platinum capsule collection.
MajorsMay 03, 2024
Kristie Nicolosi Joins WJA Board AgainNicolosi, president and CEO of The Kingswood Company, previously sat on WJA’s board from 2011 to 2018.
CollectionsMay 03, 2024
Piece of the Week: A “Bit of LUV” for the DerbyKarina Brez’s race-ready piece is a sophisticated nod to the horse-rider relationship.
CrimeMay 02, 2024
4 Indicted in Burglary Ring Targeting Indian, South Asian FamiliesThe men are allegedly responsible for stealing millions in jewelry and other valuables in 43 burglaries in 25 towns across Massachusetts.
CollectionsMay 02, 2024
Foundrae Launches ‘Horizon’ Collection“Horizon” invites individuals to explore the limitless possibilities that lie ahead, said the brand.
