Judge Rules Jeweler’s Lawsuit Against PNC Bank Can Move Forward
Joyce’s Jewelry sued the bank after cybercriminals drained its accounts of nearly $1.6 million through a series of wire transfers.
The owners of Joyce’s Jewelry in the Pittsburgh-area city of Uniontown sued PNC in September 2022 after cybercriminals stole nearly $1.6 million from the retailer’s bank accounts through a series of wire transfers.
The theft took place on the afternoon of May 12, 2022, when one of the jewelry store’s employees accidentally logged into a phony website made to look like PNC Bank’s website.
Using the employee’s login credentials obtained from the phishing website, cybercriminals emptied all four of the store’s bank accounts through 11 wire transfers sent over a period of 20 hours.
In the lawsuit, the store’s owners alleged that PNC Bank failed to keep its money safe, while PNC claimed it took the proper steps in regard to the transactions and the fault lies with Joyce’s Jewelry and its employee.
The jeweler claimed these transfers should have raised a red flag for PNC because the money was moved to accounts and businesses it had never sent money to before.
The wire amounts also were far above the usual transaction amounts, by tens of thousands of dollars per wire. Joyce’s had never wired close to $1 million in a single day.
The wires also exceeded the funds available, leading to an overdraft charge of nearly $200,000, another abnormality that should have caught the bank’s attention. Joyce’s, to its knowledge, had never overdrawn on its accounts before, the lawsuit states.
PNC did recover some of the stolen funds, and charged the jeweler for its recovery efforts, bringing the loss total down to $1.1 million.
The case brought by Joyce’s Jewelry initially went to the Court of Common Pleas of Fayette County, Pennsylvania, which is a state court.
PNC Bank asked that a federal court, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, take up the matter.
On Jan. 12, 2023, the federal court denied that request, ruling the state court should continue to handle the case.
Two weeks later, PNC filed a motion to dismiss, arguing against Joyce’s claims of negligence and breach of fiduciary duty, as well as the jeweler’s request for attorneys’ fees and punitive damages.
The bank also argued it could only be sued only under the state’s Uniform Commercial Code, which guides commercial business transactions, including wire transfers.
Earlier this year, the state court’s decision came back in favor of Joyce’s Jewelry.
In a March 11 ruling, Judge Nancy D. Vernon said the court could not dismiss claims that PNC and individual bank employees acted negligently.
She also said the jeweler can continue to seek attorneys’ fees and punitive damages in the case.
In her ruling, the judge also noted that PNC’s duty to the jeweler goes beyond its contractual obligations and said the bank may still be liable for a tort, meaning an injury or wrong independent of an implied contract.
A spokesperson from PNC said, “PNC regrets that Joyce’s Jewelry was the victim of a crime and suffered financial losses. However, Joyce’s Jewelry could have avoided being defrauded had they taken the reasonable precautions recommended by PNC at any stage of this process.
“Although the court denied PNC’s requested relief at this stage, PNC expects the facts and law will ultimately establish that PNC is not liable for Joyce’s Jewelry’s losses.”
Howard Kaplan, partner at the law firm Kaplan & Grady and Joyce’s Jewelry’s counsel, shared some insight into the case and what it could mean for other small businesses in this situation.
The recent ruling is significant, he said, because that’s not usually how these cases play out.
“Usually, [these cases] are under a very narrow legal theory and individual bank employees are not put in the mixer. And punitive damages aren’t a question, nor is tort liability for negligence,” he said.
“Usually, disputes with bank customers are a creature of contract, as opposed to tort or negligence. So, the liability on a negligence theory is broader. The potential damages and liability are broader than on a contract theory,” said Kaplan.
If the bank was able to confine the lawsuit to the Uniform Commercial Code claim, it likely would have limited the damages it may have to pay.
The judge’s March 11 ruling is “a really bad development for [PNC] because they don’t want their employees getting sued, and they don’t want to be exposed to open-ended damages,” he said.
The damages are, in part, for “gaslighting” the jeweler into believing the fault was solely theirs, and for sending the business into collections and risking its livelihood, Kaplan said.
As for how much, that’s a question for the judge and jury.
“What is it going to take to send a message to PNC that the way that they’ve treated their customer in this instance was unacceptable? And I would think that it would take a large number to send a message to them, likely a multiple of Joyce’s loss,” he said.
“The bank here is spending more on their defense than it would cost to pay Joyce’s back. They will spend more than a million dollars through trial to avoid doing right by their customer.”
Beyond the legal implications of the case, Kaplan said he wants people to understand the reality and relatability of the situation.
“They’re going to blame a 70-year-old woman for making a mistake on her computer and say what resulted—collection of all of Joyce’s cash into one account and then shipping that money out in 11 highly suspect wires over the course of 20 hours—is all fair and OK,” he said. “It’s really offensive from a common-sense perspective.”
“We didn’t say that Joyce’s did everything right. But PNC is required to have reasonable security and is required to follow those reasonable security measures in a reasonable way,” Kaplan said.
“And the facts of the case seem to show that one or the other isn’t true. Either you didn’t have the proper security in place, or you all were asleep at the switch, but it has to be one or the other because of what happened,” he said.
The case is in the preliminary stages, but Kaplan’s hope is that others in this situation can take the same approach.
“If we actually win the case, and I am confident that we will, then that roadmap will just be that much more useful and hopefully it will lead more broadly to better recoveries for defrauded customers, and there are many more out there,” said Kaplan.
The Latest
Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA
Sales will be paused while the relocation takes place over the next few months.
“SIS x MISA Denim and Diamonds” is a collaboration between the designer and celebrity stylist Misa Hylton.
Meet Ben Claus—grand prize winner of For the Love of Jewelers 2023 Fall Design Challenge.
The retailer is moving to a newly designed space in the same shopping center.
Gifts that are unique and thoughtful are top of mind this year, according to the annual survey.
The necklace is featured in the brand’s “Rebel Heart” campaign starring Adam Levine and Behati Prinsloo.
With Ho Brothers, you can unlock your brand's true potential and offer customers the personalized jewelry experiences they desire.
The two organizations will host a joint event, “Converge,” in September 2025.
Big changes appear to be on the horizon for the diamond miner and its parent company, Anglo American.
Padis succeeds Lisa Bridge, marking the first time the organization has had two women board presidents in a row.
Jesse Cole, founder of Fans First Entertainment, shared the “five Es” of building a fan base during his AGS Conclave keynote.
The Royal Oak Perpetual Calendar "John Mayer" was celebrated at a star-studded party in LA last week.
The announcement came as the company reported a 23 percent drop in production in Q1.
The three-time Pro Bowler continues to partner with the retailer, donating to a Detroit nonprofit and giving watches to fans.
A double-digit drop in the number of in-store crimes was offset by a jump in off-premises attacks, JSA’s 2023 crime report shows.
Inspired by the Roman goddess of love, the designer looked to the sea for her new collection.
The luxury titan posted declining sales, weighed down by Gucci’s poor performance.
The selected nine organizations have outlined their plans for the funds.
The mining company’s Diavik Diamond Mine lost four employees in a plane crash in January.
The crown introduced a dozen timepieces in Geneva, including a heavy metal version of its deep-sea divers’ watch.
Emmanuel Raheb recommends digging into demographic data, customizing your store’s communications, and retargeting ahead of May 12.
Located in the town of Queensbury, it features a dedicated bridal section and a Gabriel & Co. store-in-store.
A 203-carat diamond from the alluvial mine in Angola achieved the highest price.
Ruser was known for his figural jewelry with freshwater pearls and for his celebrity clientele.
The “Rebel Heart” campaign embodies rebellion, romance, and sensuality, the brand said.
Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff shares the standout moments from the education sessions she attended in Austin last week.