MajorsMar 24, 2021
The Tiffany v. Costco Battle Wages On MajorsJul 21, 2021
Tiffany, Costco Settle Long-Standing Lawsuit
The contentious battle over the term “Tiffany Setting” has come to a close via a settlement.
Tiffany & Co. reached a settlement agreement with Costco following a years-long trademark infringement lawsuit. (Image courtesy of Tiffany & Co.)
New York—The contentious, 8-year-long legal battle between Tiffany & Co. and Costco Wholesale Corp. has come to an anticlimactic end.
The companies have reached a settlement, the terms of which have not been disclosed, and the case has been dismissed with prejudice, meaning Tiffany cannot sue Costco again on the same grounds.
In a statement to National Jeweler, a lawyer representing Costco said the parties have “amicably resolved their dispute.”
Tiffany declined to comment.
The saga began Valentine’s Day of 2013 when Tiffany took Costco to court, suing the big-box retailer in New York federal court for trademark infringement, counterfeiting and unfair business practices for selling “Tiffany” rings that were not made by Tiffany.
An estimated 3,349 customers bought “Tiffany” rings at Costco during the period covered by the lawsuit, according to court documents.
Related stories will be right here …
The companies have reached a settlement, the terms of which have not been disclosed, and the case has been dismissed with prejudice, meaning Tiffany cannot sue Costco again on the same grounds.
In a statement to National Jeweler, a lawyer representing Costco said the parties have “amicably resolved their dispute.”
Tiffany declined to comment.
The saga began Valentine’s Day of 2013 when Tiffany took Costco to court, suing the big-box retailer in New York federal court for trademark infringement, counterfeiting and unfair business practices for selling “Tiffany” rings that were not made by Tiffany.
An estimated 3,349 customers bought “Tiffany” rings at Costco during the period covered by the lawsuit, according to court documents.
In a countersuit, Costco said the term “Tiffany” setting had become genericized and could be used by any company to mean a ring with multiple, slender prongs holding a single stone.
In 2015, a federal judge ruled in Tiffany’s favor and granted the jeweler’s motion for summary judgment (a judgment entered by the court without a full trial) in the case.
A jury ordered Costco to pay Tiffany $5.5 million for unlawful profits, including $3.7 million in direct profits and $1.8 million in additional benefits from the ring sales, and $8.25 million in punitive damages.
The judge trebled the $3.7 million to $11 million, for grand total of $21 million Costco was to pay Tiffany.
In August 2020, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the summary judgment on appeal from Costco.
A unanimous ruling found that if a jury had heard the case, jurors likely wouldn’t be confused by Costco’s use of the word “Tiffany” or believe the rings were made or endorsed by Tiffany & Co.
The appeals court sent the case back down to the district court to hash out the issues of punitive damages and a jury.
The case dragged on, with Costco filing a motion to prevent a jury trial and stop Tiffany from seeking punitive damages, which Tiffany disputed based on prior court rulings.
An in-person trial was possible for July, but a settlement remained on the table, as per court documents. The companies had discussed one prior to going to trial in 2016.
Tiffany v. Costco was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
More on Majors
The Latest
SourcingAug 05, 2022
Rare Earth Mining Co.’s Bill Heher Dies at 72The passionate gem lover helped bring more than 300 different varieties of stones to the gem trade.
TrendsAug 05, 2022
Piece of the Week: Storrow Jewelry’s ‘Emblem Rosa’ CharmThe brand has attracted attention for its colorful, vintage-inspired pieces.
Policies & IssuesAug 05, 2022
Satta Matturi Joins RJC BoardThe jewelry designer founded her eponymous brand in 2015 after nearly two decades in the diamond industry.
Brought to you by
The American Mined™ Collection: Ethical Sourcing That MattersRio Grande provides a pathway to responsibly sourced gemstones.
Supplier BulletinAug 04, 2022
Unusual Jewelry Finds Eager Buyers In Online AuctionsSponsored by HiBid
Weekly QuizAug 04, 2022
This Week’s QuizTest your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
WatchesAug 04, 2022
4 Takeaways from Chrono24’s Analysis of the Luxury Watch MarketThe watch seller comments on future demand, how the crypto crash impacted Rolex and Patek Philippe pricing, the supply recovery, and more.
CollectionsAug 04, 2022
The Rest of De Beers’ 2022 High Jewelry Collection Is HereIt features fives sets of jewelry.
Brought to you by
Knowledge and Skills for Today’s Hot TopicsFrom laboratory-grown diamonds to design to country-of-origin, GIA's Alumni Collective™ has a seminar to suite your needs.
Lab-GrownAug 04, 2022
Lab-Grown Diamond Co. Plasmability Partners with HRA GroupThrough the collaboration, HRA will exclusively cut, polish, and distribute Plasmability’s lab-grown diamonds in the market.
IndependentsAug 04, 2022
TJA to Offer ‘Texas Tours’ at Upcoming Round-Up EventThey include a tour of a museum’s gem collection and demonstrations of diamond cutting and polishing.
TechnologyAug 03, 2022
Tiffany Introduces CryptoPunk NFT PendantsThe limited-edition pendants, available in digital and physical form, retail for $50,000 and are exclusive to holders of CryptoPunks NFTs.
AuctionsAug 03, 2022
Elvis and Colonel Tom Parker’s ‘Lost’ Jewelry Coming to AuctionThe sale includes pieces “The King” gifted to his longtime manager, as well as jewelry Elvis owned and wore on stage.
WatchesAug 03, 2022
Breitling’s Latest Ambassador Is an NFL StarTrevor Lawrence is the quarterback for the Jacksonville Jaguars.
SourcingAug 03, 2022
Gembridge Launches Reseller Program for Colored Stones and Jewelry It gives trade members full access to its catalog of products so they can sell listings on their own online platforms.
IndependentsAug 03, 2022
Day’s Jewelers Announces New VP of Merchandising Julie Collins succeeds Kathy Corey in the role.
ColumnistsAug 02, 2022
Why Passing on Lab-Grown Diamonds Might Be a Risky BetRetailers would be wise to embrace this growing segment of the market instead of shunning it, Peter Smith writes.
SourcingAug 02, 2022
AGTA Names John Ford as Its New CEOHe’s the owner of The Lightning Ridge Collection but will pivot to focus on his new role.
TrendsAug 02, 2022
Marvel Debuts Gem-Set Infinity GauntletEast Continental Gems provided more than 150 carats of gemstones for the project.
SurveysAug 02, 2022
Consumer Confidence Falls for Third Month in JulyRising prices and interest rate hikes are expected to weigh on consumer spending and economic growth over the next six months.
TrendsAug 01, 2022
Amanda’s Style File: Peridot That PopsTo kick off August, Amanda Gizzi is sharing jewelry featuring the month’s OG birthstone.
CrimeAug 01, 2022
Joseph DuMouchelle Sentenced to 12 Years Behind Bars in $12M FraudThe Michigan auctioneer and appraiser also has to pay restitution totaling $25 million for other victims of his fraud scheme.
EditorsJul 29, 2022
The Jewelry Industry Remembers Castro: A Complicated, Magical DesignerBefore his sudden death last week, the designer had reached new creative heights.
SourcingJul 29, 2022
De Beers Sales Rise 23% YOY in July Despite unusually high summertime sales, the company’s CEO said the industry remains “watchful.”
MajorsJul 29, 2022
Jewelers of America Elects 4 New Directors to Board Joseph Corey, Krystle Craycraft, Sue Hopeman, and Sherry Smith will each serve three-year terms on the board.
TrendsJul 29, 2022
Piece of the Week: Zahn-Z Jewelry’s ‘Gem Pop’ RingA lab-grown ruby makes the perfect nostalgic treat.
Supplier BulletinJul 28, 2022
Local Jewelry Dealers Use Online Auctions To Find Bidders WorldwideSponsored by HiBid
FinancialsJul 28, 2022
Boucheron, Pomellato Deliver ‘Very Solid’ Performances for Kering Revenue for the group that includes Kering’s jewelry brands grew 32 percent in the first half of 2022.
