Merit Diamond Wins $90K in Copyright Case Against Sears

MajorsMay 19, 2017

Merit Diamond Wins $90K in Copyright Case Against Sears

The federal court in Miami issued the judgment against the department store chain and ordered it to stop selling the pendant that Merit claimed was a copy of its “Solitaire” design.

Miami--Merit Diamond Corp. has notched another legal victory protecting the intellectual property rights of its Sirena Collection.

In December, the Florida-based jewelry manufacturer filed a complaint against Sears, Roebuck & Co., Sears Holdings Management Corp., Sears Brands LLC, Kmart Operations LLC and Kmart Corp. in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida for “willful violation” of its copyright and trade dress rights related to the Sirena brand.

The company alleged that in November, one of its employees spotted a necklace similar to Merit’s Solitaire design, which was copyrighted in 2002, in a Sears store in Florida.

The same pendant also was later seen on both the Sears and Kmart websites, priced as low as $29.99, court papers state.

This picture supplied by Merit Diamond Corp. shows the pendant that a company employee purchased at a Sears store in between two “Solitaire” necklaces made by Merit. (Merit added the text to the photo.)  
Sears was once a Merit customer, selling the Sirena Collection and Solitaire design from 2003 until 2011.

Merit argued that the retailer knew about its copyright and trade dress but chose to copy the design anyway for financial gain, selling infringing necklaces at stores across the country.

On March 30, the defendants offered to allow entry of judgment to be taken against them in regards to the complaints, and Merit agreed.

The court issued a judgment in Merit’s favor April 13, ordering Sears to pay the company $90,000, which it already has done, and “further agree that any manufacture, distribution, and sale of the item claimed to be infringing by the plaintiff has stopped and will not be hereinafter recommenced,” court papers state.

After the judgement, Merit issued the following statement: “Merit Diamond Corporation has once again enforced its valuable intellectual property rights in its famous Sirena Collection in federal court in Miami, Florida. Merit successfully sued defendants Sears, Roebuck & Co., Sears Holdings Management Corporation, Sears Brands LLC, Kmart Operations LLC, Kmart Corporation, iStar Jewelry LLC, Yelnats Inc., and Stanley Creations Inc. for copyright and trade dress infringement due to their sale and manufacture of knockoff goods.”

Sears declined to comment on the judgment. 

This isn’t the first time Merit has gone to court with claims that a company was knocking off the designs in its Sirena collection--it sued Samuels Jewelers Inc. in 2009 over Sirena, as well as SK Diamonds Inc. in 2011 and Sterling Jewelers Inc. in 2012.


judge awarded Merit $7,500 in damages in the case involving SK Diamonds and prohibited the latter from making pendants that closely resembled Sirena pieces.

The Samuels and Sterling Jewelers lawsuits also were settled, though details of those settlements weren’t released.

Editor’s Note: This story was updated May 19 to reflect a response from Sears Holdings.
Brecken Branstratoris the senior editor, gemstones at National Jeweler, covering sourcing, pricing and other developments in the colored stone sector.

The Latest

AuctionsApr 16, 2021
Try On This Diamond and Pearl Tiara Before It Heads to Auction

Sotheby’s created an Instagram filter for the crown, estimated to sell for up to $1.5 million.

SurveysApr 16, 2021
March Retail Sales Surge

Another round of stimulus checks helped to bolster last month’s retail sales.

CollectionsApr 16, 2021
Supplier Kim International Revives its Catalog

It showcases 2021 and 2022 styles, with most ready to ship from Dallas, Texas.

Brought to you by
4 Reasons You Need This Program for Mother’s Day

Learn how to increase customer loyalty and revenue by making JM™ Care Plan a cornerstone of your business plan.

TrendsApr 16, 2021
Piece of the Week: Anthony Lent’s ‘Lunar Galaxy’ Earrings

Colorful gems enliven a classic celestial motif.

Weekly QuizApr 16, 2021
This Week's Quiz
Test your knowledge of jewelry news from the week of April 12-16, 2021.
Take the Quiz
TechnologyApr 15, 2021
Blue Nile Hires Amazon, Timex Execs

The jewelry retailer named a new chief operating officer and senior vice president of supply chain.

CollectionsApr 15, 2021
Check Out Stone and Strand’s First Bridal Collection

All six styles are priced under $2,000.

Brought to you by
Evaluating Your Inventory For Success in 2021 

After months of pandemic-driven social distancing, restrictions and lock-downs, consumers will be excited to visit your store. Now is the time to ensure you have the right inventory on-hand to capitalize on that excitement!

GradingApr 15, 2021
GCAL Introduces Its New Cut Grade Standard, 8X

Diamonds must receive a grade of “excellent” across eight criteria to be deemed an 8X.