Grading

Remaining lawsuits filed over EGL reports are settled

GradingDec 14, 2014

Remaining lawsuits filed over EGL reports are settled

The three remaining lawsuits filed against Tennessee retailer Genesis Diamonds over its use of EGL International grading reports have been settled.

New York--The three remaining lawsuits filed against Tennessee retailer Genesis Diamonds over its use of EGL International grading reports have been settled. 

Brian Cummings, the Nashville, Tenn.-based attorney representing the three individuals said Friday that the suits were resolved and dismissed. The terms of the settlement are confidential, though Cummings said his clients were “very satisfied” with the outcome. 

Cummings’ clients, M. Nathaniel Averitt, Richard Vien and Allan (A.J.) Zyla Jr., sued retailer Genesis Diamonds LLC and its owner Boaz Ramon earlier in the year, alleging the retailer intentionally confused consumers about the difference between “inferior” EGL International-graded diamonds and those graded by the Gemological Institute of America. 

“Genesis Diamonds’ business practice for many years has been to offer inferior-quality EGL International diamonds as equivalent to GIA certified diamonds. Genesis employees and sales staff falsely claim that the only difference between diamonds certified by the two laboratories is ‘the price,’” the lawsuit states. “By doing so, Genesis is able to claim it is offering a diamond ‘at wholesale pricing’ when, in reality, it is simply selling an over-graded stone that it acquired at a steep discount comparable to a GIA diamond.

“The practice allows Genesis Diamonds to simultaneously reap a profit margin that would not be possible selling legitimately-graded GIA diamonds, while falsely claiming they have saved the customer money.” 

In his lawsuit, Averitt stated that he bought cufflinks with 3-carat diamonds that were both color graded as G but later re-evaluated as M and N color diamonds. He also bought a diamond eternity band with diamonds graded as F that later were re-evaluated as J color stones. Both pieces appraised at a significantly lower price than Averitt originally was led to believe, the lawsuit states. 

Vien and Zyla had a similar experience with diamond engagement rings, court papers show. 

Eli Richardson, the attorney representing Genesis Diamonds, also confirmed the settlement but did not provide a comment on behalf of the retailer.

The lawsuits brought by consumers in Tennessee was one of the major factors that touched off a recent chain of reactions to a problem that has long been simmering--over-graded diamonds. 

In October, Martin Rapaport removed all EGL-graded diamonds from his diamond trading network, RapNet.

Just last week, news surfaced that the owners of the EGL brand (meaning EGL labs outside the United States; EGL USA is separate and not affiliated) had appointed a new global manager

to clean up the lab’s practices and would no longer be using the EGL International brand name. 
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

MajorsSep 24, 2021
Brilliant Earth Is Now a Public Company

CEO Beth Gerstein said she believes in the jeweler’s omnichannel approach as its retail rollout continues.

Events & AwardsSep 24, 2021
These 3 Companies Will Receive Business Grants from PGI USA

PGI created the program to accelerate the growth of the platinum jewelry market in the U.S.

CollectionsSep 24, 2021
Zales Introduces Elvis Presley Men’s Jewelry Line

From its curb link chains to statement diamond rings, the new collection takes inspiration from the “King of Rock ‘n’ Roll.”

Brought to you by
Bringing Sexy Back: The Allure of COUTURE, Italian Style

Take a tour of Italian designers at COUTURE 2021.

TrendsSep 24, 2021
Piece of the Week: Mateo’s Initial Pendant

It’s a trendy take on personalization.

Weekly QuizSep 23, 2021
This Week's Quiz
Test your knowledge of jewelry news from the week of Sept. 20-24, 2021.
Take the Quiz
CrimeSep 23, 2021
5 Men Who Fenced Stolen Diamonds Get 15 Years in Prison

They bought and resold jewels from a South America-based gang that targeted traveling salespeople across the United States.

SourcingSep 23, 2021
Joanna Hardy Completes Gemstone Trilogy with ‘Sapphire’ Book

It’s the follow-up to “Emerald” and “Ruby.”

Brought to you by
What is your Health Care Coverage Strategy?

Health care coverage is a big expense for small businesses - find out how to lower costs long-term instead of every 12 months.

MajorsSep 23, 2021
Claire’s To Offer Subscription Service

The quarterly themed boxes will feature on-trend jewelry, hair accessories, handbags, and more.

×